Diapers

Pampers Swaddlers vs. Pampers Baby Dry Diapers: Who Wins?

Last Updated on

Whenever you have two products from the same brand, it can be hard to figure out which is best and how different from each other they really are. And when you look at the main differences between Pampers Swaddlers vs. Pampers Baby Dry Diapers, you can see the dilemma. On the one hand, they are from the same brand, so naturally, some parents might assume that both diapers offer the same overall quality and the rest shouldn’t matter. But when you examine them both a little more closely, you can see where one might excel and the other might need to pick up the slack.

For starters, Pampers Baby Dry Diapers have the same wetness indicator line that Pampers Swaddlers do. However, only sizes newborn, one, and two of the Baby Dry have this small but beneficial feature. Then again, while Swaddlers do have the Absorb Away liner, the Baby Dry Diapers offers three entire layers of protection. As most parents can agree, having as many layers of absorption for overnight diapers is a total must.

While both diapers do offer absorbency and the precautions to ensure that the diapers don’t leak, there are cases where that happens. And often, that has a lot to do with the way the diapers actually fit on your baby. If a diaper doesn’t fit your baby properly, there could be tiny gaps in the leg openings that allow for leaks whether you mean for them to or not. And when it comes down to it, Pampers Swaddlers just have a better overall fit. In the long run, this can be a deciding factor for some parents.

Obviously, it is going to come down to the smallest but most important details of Swaddlers and Baby Dry Diapers in order to figure out which one is the stronger option. But before you make your final decision and decide what kind of family you are — a Swaddlers family or a Baby Dry family — consider all they have to offer and all they might also lack.

Main Differences Pampers Swaddlers vs. Pampers Baby Dry

baby in diaper

The Main Differences Between the Pampers Swaddlers and Pampers Baby Dry are:

  • Fit. Judging by the individual reviews of both diaper sub-brands, the Pampers Swaddlers have the most comfortable and accurate fit for babies.

  • Absorbency layers. While Swaddlers have a special layer for extra absorbency, Baby Dry Diapers do have those three layers of protection that can’t be beaten.

  • Baby Dry Diapers are a little more comfortable because, unlike Swaddlers, they don’t have a slight stiffness to them.

  • The wetness indicator in Swaddlers is available in all sizes.

Pampers Swaddlers Diapers

pampersFor some parents, going with Pampers Swaddlers Diapers is a no brainer. They come from an already reputable brand and they offer ease of use and plenty of absorbency, which is especially beneficial for new parents who might need that helping hand more than anyone. Swaddlers are also, however, designed to be soft against your baby’s skin, which is also a big plus got sensitive infant skin.

Swaddlers are now made with Pampers’ own Heart Quilts liner, which is made to be twice as soft as standard diapers. Swaddlers also have an “umbilical cord notch,” which is essentially a dip in the front of the diaper for newborns who still have that tiny piece connected to their belly button. The diaper in that area contours to protect your baby’s delicate skin and keep him or her comfortable.

Swaddlers also have stretchy clasps on each side that are easy to pull to get the right fit as you move between sizes. And because they are so stretchy, they can make it easier for your baby to move without any discomfort from the diaper. Just in case absorbency is literally your only concern, though, Swaddlers have the Absorb Away liner that pulls moisture away from your baby’s skin to hold in the diaper and help prevent rashes and irritation. As a result, the diapers advertise up to 12 hours of protection.

But since new parents might have a hard time knowing for sure when to change a full diaper, the wetness indicator line on the diapers will change color. That way, your baby’s diaper doesn’t get too full and you also don’t waste any diapers that aren’t ready to be changed just yet. Clearly, if you’re looking for comfort, absorbency, and diapers that can grow with your child through each stage, that is the goal with Pampers Swaddlers.

Features

  • Absorbency Features: Swaddlers have an Absorb Away liner to pull moisture from your baby’s skin. This is meant to help in absorbing more moisture than the standard filling that is found in other diaper brands.

  • Fit: They are made with stretchy tabs on each side and have a contoured front to keep your infant comfortable.

  • Available Sizes: Swaddlers come in sizes from newborn, which is less than 10 pounds, to 7, which is for little ones who are 41 pounds and up.

  • Where To Buy: You can find them on Amazon or in-store at Target and Walmart.

  • Has This Item Been Recalled?: There are no recent or current recalls on Pamper Swaddlers.

Pros

  • They come in sizes to see your child through all of their diaper wearing years.

  • The wetness indicator is featured on all sizes, which can be beneficial regardless of how old your baby is.

  • The umbilical cord notch is helpful for parents with newborns since all babies need to wear diapers, regardless of how “new” they are.

  • Swaddlers also have a soft lining since newborn skin is typically more sensitive and in need of soft “fabric.”

  • The waistband and side tabs are stretchy to get a comfortable fit on your baby.

Cons

  • Swaddlers might run a little small for some babies.

  • Although they advertise up to 12 hours of protection, babies still might experience blowouts or leaks overnight.

  • Swaddlers have soft material, but can sometimes feel overall stiff.

  • In general, Swaddlers handle wetness better than stools.

Pampers Swaddlers Price: $47.52 The reason why I love Pampers Swaddlers is because they are softer than many other brands, have wetness indicator and keep my baby dry all night. Plus, for such a price you will have a month supply for sure! Buy Now from Amazon Pampers Swaddlers We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you. Last Updated: August 25, 2019

Reviews

“Swaddlers are what they started us with at the hospital, and what we’ve continued to use. We very rarely had a leak (even with massive amounts of wee wee), and they really seem to keep the little one dry.” – Michael A. Behr on Amazon.

“The Pampers Swaddlers are just a solid product. The wetness indicator is just icing on the cake. I’ve tried the Baby Dry line and had to switch back to Swaddlers… The Baby Dry is a good product also but I will stick with swaddlers from now on.” – Victor Trang on Amazon.

“The only brand of diapers I will ever buy. Swaddlers has the best leak protection hands down. It has a blue line on them that appears when the diaper is wet as well. Also, Swaddlers have a nice powdery scent to them.” – Sarah M. on Amazon.

“These are the perfect diaper for little babies! I love that they have that baby powder smell. They are soft on the baby’s skin and very absorbent. I have used this diaper for my sons and my daughter and have found them to be effective for both genders.” – K. Lutz on Amazon.

Pampers Baby Dry Diapers

pampers baby dry

Because Pampers Baby Dry Diapers are from the same brand as Swaddlers, it’s no surprise that they share some of the same important qualities. So you can also expect some serious absorbency and softness with these in order to keep your little one from having frequent leaks and to keep him or her comfortable. They are also diapers that can be worn for years, thanks to the many sizes they come in. And, as to be expected, the name says it all in dryness.

Baby Dry Diapers have a cotton softness and three layers of absorbency to keep your babies dry for up to 12 hours. That doesn’t necessarily mean they will be without the middle of the night leaks, but they can come pretty close to it with Baby Dry. And like Swaddlers, Baby Dry Diapers feature that handy wetness indicator. Though in this case, you will only find it on sizes newborn, one, and two. Still, that might be enough to sway some parents to Baby Dry Diapers.

These ones also have three absorb channels to keep wetness away from your baby’s skin. One of the main reasons why babies tend to break out in rashes with diapers is because of the way the diapers react to their skin when wetness remains there for long periods of time. With the absorb channels on Baby Dry Diapers, you can ensure that you’re giving your baby the right diaper to keep most of that moisture away from their sensitive and delicate skin.

Baby Dry Diapers also have that convenient cutout in the front for newborns’ umbilical cord remnants. It might not be a deal-breaker for some parents if diapers don’t have these, but it’s another thing that Baby Dry Diapers do indeed offer. When it’s all said and done, the goal of Pampers Baby Dry Diapers seems to be softness, absorbency, and overall comfort. And you really can’t deny how important all of those are for your baby’s daily diapers.

Features

  • Absorbency Features: Baby Dry Diapers have three absorbency layers and three different absorb channels to keep moisture from staying on your baby’s skin.

  • Fit: These diapers form around legs more easily and comfortably without any stiff portions to prevent comfort.

  • Available Sizes: Baby Dry Diapers come in sizes from zero, which is for babies who are less than 10 pounds, to size 6, which is for little ones who weigh up to 35 pounds.

  • Where To Buy: You can find these diapers on Amazon or in-store at Walmart and Target.

  • Has This Item Been Recalled?: There are no recent or current recalls on Pampers Baby Dry Diapers.

Pros

  • They have flexible tabs on each side for the perfect fit.

  • There is a wetness indicator stripe on three of the smaller sizes of Baby Dry Diapers.

  • Absorbency is key, thanks to three layers of protection and three absorb channels.

  • Thanks to the snug and stretchy fit in the legs, leaks are rare with Baby Dry compared to other diapers.

Cons

  • These diapers may run on the smaller size for some babies.

  • They can also take on a sagging look to them, even if they aren’t soiled.

  • Swaddlers are also softer, even if they might seem stiffer.

  • The tape on the straps can be a little flimsy and sometimes rip off.

Pampers Swaddlers Price: $47.52 The reason why I love Pampers Swaddlers is because they are softer than many other brands, have wetness indicator and keep my baby dry all night. Plus, for such a price you will have a month supply for sure! Buy Now from Amazon Pampers Swaddlers We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you. Last Updated: August 25, 2019

Reviews

“These diapers hold up great and especially during the night. Before buying these we had to use overnight diapers for my super soaker, so far we have had no leaks!” – Marsha Greenwood on Amazon.

“I tried out the new Pampers Baby Dry and love them! They now have a similar design to the Swaddlers and Cruisers with more channels for absorption. I found them to keep my little one very dry, especially at night, without leaving her skin feeling damp.” – Melissa Meier on Amazon.

“We really like these diapers. They keep our son pretty dry throughout the night. We were using Pampers Swaddlers but our son was waking up wet in the night. We also didn’t like the fit of the Swaddlers.” – Derek Corry on Amazon.

“These are possibly the best diapers on the market. Pampers definitely stand out from the rest, from the softness of the material to its super absorptive properties. These diapers certainly work well overnight.” – Susan Cheung on Amazon.

The Verdict

Pampers diapers, in general, are designed to give you the most absorbency and comfort for your value. But when it comes to figuring out the differences between Pampers Swaddlers and Pampers Baby Dry Diapers and which is best, the better option is the Pamper Swaddlers.

The Baby Dry do have multiple channels and layers of absorption to keep wetness away from your baby and his or her skin. But Swaddlers have wetness indicators in every single brand, they go up to size seven rather than just six, and they provide a softness you can’t really ignore. Yes, Pamper Go Dry are in a similar tier, but that’s why it’s important to look at them both closely and figure out which is the stronger option.

Because Swaddlers are made with newborns and younger babies in mind, it’s no big surprise that they are also, at their core, softer against the skin. But since they come in larger sizes, that softness translates to the other sizes, which only increases the value of Swaddlers.

Swaddlers also have that handy Absorb Away liner to not only pull wetness, but also stool way from your baby’s body. This can even result in less smelly diapers, though you should always change diapers as soon as you know they need to be changed. Your baby and your nostrils will thank you later. When it’s all said and done, both diapers offer plenty, but the Pampers Swaddlers are the better option and you just can’t go wrong with them.

Final Thoughts

pampers

Researching the best kind of diapers probably isn’t something you imagined you would ever be doing before you became a parent. But it can be the difference between spending too much money on diapers that your baby leaks through and choosing the right brand to last your family until your baby no longer needs diapers at all.

The main differences between Pampers Swaddlers and Pampers Baby Dry Diapers might not be as plain as day at first, but when you look a little closer, you can see what they each bring to the table. There is nothing wrong with Baby Dry, of course, and being from Pampers, these diapers are also top of the line. But Swaddlers offer the absorbency, comfort, and softness in every single size that your baby needs. If you are looking for the diaper to stick with for the long haul, then it’s Pampers Swaddlers.

Recommended Reads:

Leave a Reply