Last Updated on
Once you decide that you’ll be needing a reliable breast pump in the months and perhaps even years ahead during motherhood, you then have to decide what you look for in one and whether or not the Hygeia Enjoye vs. the Medela Pump In Style will work for you.
In some ways, just going with your sister’s or your best friend’s recommendation to pick a breast pump system more easily and quickly might seem like the fastest route to making that decision. But in other ways, you could be missing out on qualities you need and want in a good pump.
Whether this is your first pregnancy or you’ve already been there and done that several times before, that doesn’t mean you should think lightly of choosing between the Hygeia Enjoye vs the Medela Pump In Style.
Bottom Line up Front: I loved my Medela Pump in Style, but I was VERY surprised at how much I ended up liking the Hygeia. In the end, the versatile compatibility with different brands and the flexible charging options make the Hygeia available here my favorite.
A Little About Both Pumps
Both breast pumps offer systems that are portable and simple enough to take with you pretty much anywhere so you can pump when you’re away from home, which is especially useful while at work.
Unlike your work schedule, your milk production is not on the most predictable timeline, so it’s always a good idea to have your pump nearby, and both of these make that plenty convenient.
It’s only natural, however, that each pump has its differences. Where the Medela Pump In Style comes with a cooler bag and ice pack insert to allow up to four bottles to fit comfortable after pumping, the small insulated bag that comes with the Hygeia Enjoye is much smaller. This means that you may have to find another way to properly store your pumped milk before you can take it home.
On the flipside, the Hygeia Enjoye allows you four hours of charge on its built-in rechargeable battery, whereas the Medela Pump In Style requires you to supply your own eight AA batteries. But before you make any rash decisions, take a good long look at what the Hygeia Enjoye vs. the Medela Pump In Style offers to make your breast pumping experience go smoothly for you.
Because of its long life and ease of use, not to mention functionality, the Hygeia Enjoye is a hospital-grade breast pump meant to help you get the job done right from the beginning.
The set comes with a carrying bag as well as containers with lids you can store your pumped breast milk in and two valves and suction cups that can be used at the same time. Not only that, but you can also use the individual controls to change the speed and power of the suction to mimic your baby’s sucking indeed and to get the most out of each pumping session.
The pump can be plugged into an outlet if you wish, but it also has a lithium rechargeable battery to be able to use it while away from home.
Plus, all of the parts that come into contact with the breast milk are safe and BPA-free so you’ll always have peace of mind that once you feed your baby with the pumped milk, it will still be safe enough for them.
Although the pump comes with a variety of parts to use with it, if you already have breast pump parts for your Medela, you can still use those with this machine. And because you get a rechargeable battery, you’ll never have to worry about buying new replacement batteries.
- Control Buttons: The Hygeia Enjoye has two dials to control both the speed and strength of the suction.
- Battery Life: The rechargeable battery has a life of four hours before you’ll need to charge it again.
- Bag & Accessories: It comes with a storage carrying bag, small cooler bag meant to fit one of the bottles of pumped milk, two tubings, and two 27 mm flanges.
- Price: On Amazon, the Hygeia Enjoye is $200. Check out the latest price!
- Where To Buy: You can find the pump on the manufacturer’s website and Amazon. Also, you can see if you qualify for a FREE breast pump via Aeroflow Breast Pumps here.
- You’ll never have to replace any batteries, which will save you some money in the long run.
- You can personalize the pump by turning the dials to figure out which speed and suction strength work best for you.
- The set comes with two storage bottles that each hold up to four ounces of milk.
- Some Medela parts, as well as some Avent bottles, will attach reasonably well to the pump so you can also use those accessories if you already have them and prefer them.
- While the sound of the pump isn’t exactly loud, it is noisier than some other breast pumps and might be annoying to some.
- The flanges may not be suitable for everyone, depending on their size.
- At times, milk may get stuck or “lost” in the tubes, which can be frustrating, mainly if you aren’t producing breast milk very much at a time.
Hygeia Enjoye Reviews
“I bought this so that I can keep a pump at work. This is an expensive brand, but I’ve tried a cheaper kind, and in my experience, it is a good investment. It is powerful, and the battery can recharge.” – Rachel K. Tan on Amazon.
“I have been using this pump for the last nine months. I had oversupply for the first several months and then went back to work full time, so I have logged a lot of time with my pump. Having the internal battery has been amazing! It holds a charge for a surprisingly long time.” – KristIn Hart on Amazon.
“I’m a first-time mother and never used a breast pump before and love this one. It’s comfortable and expresses milk quickly. I would highly recommend!” – Stephanie Huey on Amazon.
“Love love love this pump! I’m a flight attendant & can only sneak into the laboratory for 10 minutes at a time. The rechargeable batteries mean I can maintain my supply without having to plugin. The double pump, speed & suction controls allow for a speedy pump.” – K. Dilley on Amazon.
Medela Pump In Style
The Medela has plenty of different pumps to choose from, including the Medela Pump in Style which is portable if you choose to use batteries instead of the AC adapter.
And although it means you’ll have to have a steady supply of batteries in your home or the bag with you, it still means that the breast pump can be used pretty much anywhere, which is the point. The entire set makes it even more possible to take the pump with you away from home since it has a portable bag that the pump sits inside and a small cooler bag that can fit four bottles of breast milk along with the contoured ice pack.
Again, total convenience there, especially since you may pump a considerable amount, depending on how long you’re away from home.
And when it’s not in use, literally everything that comes with the pump, including the cooler bag, fits inside of the more significant carrying bag so you can keep track of everything whether you’re at work or just out of the house for the day. It also has two pumps that can be used at once for added convenience.
- Control Buttons: There is one control button on the front of the pump, which works to control the speed of pumping.
- Battery Life: You can either plug in the Medela Pump In Style or use eight AA batteries.
- Bag & Accessories: The pump comes with a storage carrying bag, cooler bag with ice pack, four different breastmilk bottles with lids, breast shield, a bottle nipple, and a power adapter.
- Price: On Amazon, the Medela Pump In Style is $216. Check out the latest price!
- Where To Buy: You can find the breast pump on the manufacturer’s website and Amazon or in-store at Target and Walmart. You can check if you qualify for a FREE breast pump via Aeroflow Breast Pumps here.
- The cooler bag, which holds four bottles as well as the ice pack, adds a huge amount of convenience to the whole kit.
- You can control the speed with which the pump works to help draw out your breast milk.
- The sound of the pump itself isn’t particularly loud or quiet, but instead like a purring cat, but that means it won’t be making a loud annoying sound in the middle of the night.
- As long as you have the proper be to allow you to do so, you can quickly pump with both suctions at once.
- Since it doesn’t have a rechargeable battery, you may grow tired of spending money on batteries, especially since the Medela Pump In Style requires eight AA batteries.
- In some case, one side of the suctions may be stronger than the other.
- The nipples that come with the set are fast flow, which is very unlikely to work with your newborn or young infant.
Medela Pump in Style User Reviews
“I had this pump with my now four years old and was able to give her only breastmilk until her second birthday! So when I got pregnant this time, I knew I was getting this again and as usual, it doesn’t disappoint! This is the only pump I will recommend to friends and family.” – Kelsie Roberts on Amazon.
“I love this system. In love, infatuated, whatever you want to call it. If it weren’t for this system, I would not have been able to give my daughter breast milk when I had to go back to work. I would have had to switch to formula. This thing, with the cooler, ice pack, battery pack, and everything else (pockets, what-what!) is awesometastic.” – P. Bennett on Amazon.
“Can’t say enough about the quality and versatility of this product. The company hit one out of the park! Everything was designed with mom and baby in mind and has worked perfectly. Everything arrived quickly and in perfect condition. This product will last easily through several children.” – Sandra Y. Lowe on Amazon.
“So glad I bought this before giving birth. No one warned me of the possible difficulties with breastfeeding! I needed this pump within the first weeks of giving birth to my son due to latch difficulties. I have brought this to campgrounds, offices and in the car!” – Shelly Beard on Amazon.
The Verdict: Medela Pump in Style or Hygeia?
Although both breast pumps do plenty regarding making pumping on the go easy and accessible and both are roughly the same price. At the end of the day, the stronger options is going to be the Hygeia Enjoye pump.
While the Medela Pump in Style Medela Pump In Style is undoubtedly one of the more recognizable and even more famous breast pumps out there, the most prominent upsides are its larger cooler bag and the quiet purring sound of the pump, they aren’t enough to make it the stronger contender of the two.
You can keep a relatively long charge for the Hygeia Enjoye and never have to worry about replacing any batteries. You can even use some Medela parts and accessories with it, which is a big plus for parents who might already have different breast pump parts lying around but who wish to make the change to a new pump.
With the Hygeia Enjoye, you can also quickly adjust both the pace and strength in its settings to get the right feel and pressure you may specifically need to properly pump. All around, it’s going to be the more robust choice right now and in the long run.
Bottom Line: I loved my Medela Pump in Style, but I was VERY surprised at how much I ended up liking the Hygeia. In the end, the versatile compatibility with different brands and the flexible charging options make the Hygeia available here my favorite.
The Final Pump
There’s nothing glamorous about breastfeeding or pumping by any means, but if you can find the right pumping system to make the experience more comfortable and even faster for you, then it’s already done more than enough for you.
Your breast milk could come in at random times throughout the day and evening, and if you’re not at home, it can be both a painful and uncomfortable situation to be unable to pump for some time.
With the Hygeia Enjoye provided that it’s charged, you can discreetly and comfortable pump no matter where you are. And even if the battery isn’t fully charged, you can always take advantage of the power cord. Overall, it won’t be hard to get plenty of use out of the breast pump, and as long as you’re able to check off all of your most important qualities for a good breast pump, it should be the right one for you.
Further Breast Pump Research
If you are still stuck, we definitely have some additional research on breast pumps available:
- Medela Pump in Style vs Ameda Purely Yours Pump
- Best Travel Breast Pumps
- Best Manual Breast Pumps: When power isn’t an option (or just for emergencies – think about it…)
- Best Double Electric Breast Pumps: When 2X the output is required!
- Best Spectra Pumps: Useful to know, particularly if this is one of the few options your insurance covers.
- How to Get a Breast Pump Through Insurance: Speaking of which, here’s how you can get a pump free thru your insurance.