When you have a breast pump brand like Spectra, it’s hard to choose which one is the best one. The brand offers just a few electric pump options, but when it comes down to it, which is the best Spectra breast pump overall? Each option may be better than the last, which makes choosing between the four pumps that much harder. The Spectra S1 Plus and S2 Plus are similar enough in design, but then you have the Spectra 9 Plus, which is a much more compact and portable option from the Spectra brand. And the Dew 350 is perfect for babies who need milk more frequently.
If true portability is what you’re looking for, then the Spectra 9 Plus may be best for you. But the S1 and S2 Plus options do offer strong motors and a potentially more powerful pumping experience if that’s what you need. Obviously your choice between the four pumps is going to rely heavily on your specific needs, so first, you need to look at all three options to determine what Spectra pump is best. Not necessarily which one is the be all/end all best pump, but which is the best for you and your needs.
- 1 Spectra S1 Plus Breast Pump
- 2 Spectra S2 Plus Breast Pump
- 3 Spectra 9 Plus Breast Pump
- 4 Spectra Dew 350 Breast Pump
- 5 The Verdict
Spectra S1 Plus Breast Pump
The Spectra S1 Plus Breast Pump is easily one of the top pumps out there period, let alone one of the better Spectra pumps. But what sets it apart from the other impressive electric pumps from the Spectra brand is its rechargeable battery and also the ability to use the pump with the accompanying AC adapter. It also has a closed pumping system so you can be sure that no milk will leak into the tubes and no airflow will get through.
As a hospital grade pump, you can use it as a single or a double and thanks to its lightweight design, it’s fairly easy to take it with you anywhere you might need it away from home. It has let-down and expression modes to get the most out of each pumping session as well as 12 different suction levels to choose from. The pump itself comes with two bottles for storing milk and also feeding on if needed, a power cord and adapter, and two different sizes of breast flanges.
- Ease Of Use: You can use it discreetly away from home and then store it away when it’s not in use, and it’s simple to get used to the controls on the panel on top.
- Battery Or Wall Plugin: This one has a built-in rechargeable battery but also comes with an AC wall adapter.
- Cleaning: Since the pump has a closed tubing system, you don’t need to clean the inside of the tubes, but you can wipe the outside of the pump with an antibacterial wipe.
- Price: On Amazon, the Spectra S1 Plus Breast Pump is $200. Check out the latest prices on Amazon.
- Where To Buy: You can purchase it on the manufacturer’s website and on Amazon or in-store at Buy Buy Baby.
- Has This Item Been Recalled?: There are no recent, or current recalls on the Spectra S1 Plus.
- It has a massage mode to ease you into pumping each time.
- The motor is relatively quiet, which allows for easy pumping at the office if needed.
- It has a built-in rechargeable battery.
- While you can’t attach the pump to your waistband, it is lightweight enough to carry around the house as you pump.
- There are 12 suction levels to choose from.
- While it does have a rechargeable battery, the battery itself lasts only three hours per charge.
- Once you charge the pump, it can take several hours to get a full charge.
- The nightlight feature on the pump’s display can contribute to the battery losing charge more quickly.
- New parts for the pump, such as other breast flanges, are on the pricier side.
“Wow. Just wow. Why did I not hear of this pump sooner? Comfortable, portable, lightweight, oh and more than double the milk!! Seriously, it is almost a crime that the insurance companies just give out inferior pumps when this is available.” – Candice Hansen on Amazon.
“I cannot say enough good things about this pump. I have tried Ameda (throw it in the ocean or burn it), Medela pump in style (decent pump) and I have tried the golden cup of pumps (Medela Symphony), but Spectra is the best for affordable home pumps. They are gentle and collect more milk than the Medela and Ameda. It is portable with customization settings and gentle suckling action.” – K. Fenton on Amazon.
“Wonderful pump! I am an exclusive pumper due to latching issues with our month-old baby, so I needed a really good pump as we were going to spend a lot of time together. I originally had an Ameda Purely Yours pump that was free with insurance. I had so much pain with the Ameda and went out on a limb to buy this Spectra out of pocket from others recommending it. So glad I did! This pump is so much more gentle and I am even getting several ounces more with each pump.” – Nicholas Rizkalla on Amazon.
Spectra S2 Plus Breast Pump
The Spectra S2 Plus Breast Pump is almost identical to the S1 in appearance, but it does have some major differences namely, that it requires an electrical outlet and doesn’t run on a battery at all. While some might write it off for that fact, it does mean that you won’t have to worry about keeping a full charge on it or having it die while using it away from home. And unlike the S1, the S2 is just 2.5 pounds, which makes it even easier to take with you.
It also has an easy to understand LCD display which has a nightlight for those inevitable middle of the night pumping sessions. You can use it as either a single or a double pump, but in either mode, it still pumps as much and won’t lose much suction. And speaking of suction, the Spectra S2 Plus has 12 different levels to choose from. This puts it above some Spectra pumps in that regard as well as pumps from other brands.
- Ease Of Use: You can use it as a single or double pump, and the control buttons are easy to use and see thanks to the nightlight.
- Battery Or Wall Plugin: The S2 Plus is an electric pump that requires an outlet rather than a battery charge.
- Cleaning: You can wipe down the machine and sterilize the parts of the pump in a pot of boiling water.
- Price: On Amazon, the Spectra S2 Plus Breast Pump is $215. SCheck out the latest prices on Amazon.
- Where To Buy: You can purchase it on the manufacturer’s website and on Amazon or in-store at Buy Buy Baby.
- Has This Item Been Recalled?: There are no recent, or current recalls on the Spectra S2 Plus.
- It’s more lightweight than the S1 Plus, which is really saying something since the S1 Plus is also light.
- Although some may not like that it doesn’t have a battery, there is less of a chance of the pump dying.
- It also has a nightlight for reading the button panel in the middle of the night.
- You can use Medela flanges and pump parts for it, which is convenient if you already have those accessories anyway.
- It has a backflow protector so that no milk will leak into the tubes.
- It does require a wall outlet, which some moms on the go might find off-putting.
- Portability isn’t as prevalent with this one since there’s no battery involved.
- After frequent use, the tubing can become a little stretched out and might need to be held into place as you pump.
- Sometimes the suction can be almost too strong.
“I was formerly a Medela pumper (like most people), but wanted to see if there was something better. It turns out, the Spectra S2 is fantastic! It’s so quiet and sounds like a little drum roll rather than a super loud “WEE-OO! WEE-OO!” There are more parts, but the additional parts seem to do a great job keeping the milk from going back into the tubing. And you can clean the tubing – fantastic.” – Emily C. on Amazon.
“So I’ve been using a Medela pump since coming home from the hospital. I heard from a friend about this pump and she was right! This pump is quiet. So much more so than the medela. This pump doesn’t pump, it suckles. I get a letdown almost immediately and get milk steadily for about ten minutes.” – Jennifer Flaherty on Amazon.
“I rarely write reviews but this is hands down the best pump. I am an exclusive pumper and own a Medela Sonata and PISA as well as rent a hospital grade Symphony. After switching to Spectra, I immediately saw an increase of about an ounce per session. Not only that, but since starting to use Spectra, my nipples are healing from using the Symphony.” – Andrea DiFrancesco on Amazon.
Spectra 9 Plus Breast Pump
The Spectra 9 Plus Breast Pump is easily one of the more overall portable pumps out there, and as a Spectra pump, it’s a top option for sure. It weighs less than one pound, and even though it is so small and slim, it can be a double or single pump.
The 9 Plus offers up to 10 different levels, so there are less than both the S1 and S2, but it can still be the primary pump for some moms. It also has a whisper quiet motor and can be recharged overnight to get used out of it the following day. While some of the other Spectra pumps can be used on the go as well, they’re still not quite as compact and sleek as this one, and that alone makes it stand out in a good way. It does come with an AC adapter in case you need it and two bottles to pump into and store milk in for later use.
- Ease Of Use: The small controls on the front of the compact pump are easy to use, and the pump itself can be taken literally anywhere thanks to its compact size.
- Battery Or Wall Plugin: It has a rechargeable battery built-in.
- Cleaning: It’s crucial to handwash all parts of the pump and wipe down the pump itself.
- Price: On Amazon, the Spectra 9 Plus Breast Pump is $180. Check out the latest prices on Amazon.
- Where To Buy: You can find it on the manufacturer’s website and on Amazon or in store at Target.
- Has This Item Been Recalled?: There are no recent, or current recalls on this Spectra pump.
- It’s truly easy to use this pump anywhere without having a large base out to control out in the open.
- You can use it as a single or double pump.
- The battery life could give you a handful of solid pump sessions throughout the day before it needs a charge again.
- The display is easy to read and operate.
- The warranty on the motor doesn’t span as long as that of other Spectra pumps.
- The power button is a little sensitive, so it might turn on while in your diaper bag or pocket.
- Although it is strong for such a small pump, you may not get as many ounces in one session as you would for other Spectra pumps.
- At times, there may be some leaking around the flanges.
“I have a this and the Spectra 2 pump and love them both. I’m an exclusive pumper so having efficient pumps are essential. This is great, so I can be on the go and get things done around the house while pumping. I can usually get 4-25 minute sessions out of a charge. It’s louder than the Spectra 2 but not too distracting.” – Sarah P. on Amazon.
“Love this pump. I also have the Spectra S2, but if I could choose just one, I would choose the S9. I barely use my S2 now that I have this. Massage setting may be slightly weaker than the S2, but the expression setting i find to be stronger! Level 9/10 seem to be even stronger suction than my S2. Having the portability is so convenient.” – Lindsay P. on Amazon.
“I found this pump while searching for extra bottles to use with my S1. Wow, I’m so glad I did. It is super light and small and has all the power I personally need. Great for travel or pumping at work. Only negative is that it’s a little louder than the S1, but still quieter than the medelas I’ve seen.” – Elizabeth Coyne Catania on Amazon.
Spectra Dew 350 Breast Pump
The Spectra Dew 350 Breast Pump is one of the more expensive pumps out there as far as the Spectra brand goes. It’s also a little different in its design than the S1 and S2, which further sets it apart from them. But it does have a dial on the top that’s easy to use and makes it easy to adjust the settings to get the most comfortable and effective pump during every session. It’s also a hospital grade pump, so you’ll get a strong motor and suction out of it, but it does mean that it’s not a very compact pump as it is.
Though for some moms, it’s worth it to get the multiple levels of suction during pumping. It is an electric pump that uses a plug only and doesn’t have a built-in battery of any kind, but you can get as many as eight pumping sessions per day and still get the same strength from it. And although it’s a double pump, it can also be used as a single breast pump if that’s what you need.
- Ease Of Use: The dial control is easy to use and maybe even more accessible than the control buttons on the other Spectra pumps.
- Battery Or Wall Plugin: The Spectra Dew 350 uses an electric outlet.
- Cleaning: You should wash all parts of the pump by hand and not in the dishwasher.
- Price: On the manufacturer’s website, the Spectra Dew 350 Breast Pump is $249.
- Where To Buy: You can primarily find it on the manufacturer’s website.
- Has This Item Been Recalled?: There are no recent, or current recalls on this Spectra breast pump.
- It’s perfect for preemie babies who need more milk, as it does help moms build up a larger supply.
- You don’t need to do extensive cleaning to sanitize this one.
- It not only comes with a handful of bottles to pump into, but it can also be used with other bottles and breastmilk bags.
- Even if it is heavier than other Spectra pumps, it’s still small enough to take with you if you need to pump away from home.
- Unlike other Spectra pumps, there’s no digital display.
- It is a little pricier than the other pumps as well.
- There’s no massage mode to start off pumping sessions.
- After using the pump for a longer session, it can get warmer to the point where it might seem like it’s going to overheat.
“This is it, people. (Or maybe the other Spectra model, which is apparently a little louder but battery-powered and portable.) It’s good-looking, well-built, quiet, and works great. And it comes with a really top-notch set of accessories: a nice bag with a quilted black exterior and handsome plaid interior, six bottles with sealing discs and a nipple, a cooler and ice pack, and two adapters that convert the Medela-style threads to Avent-style.” – Chris B. on Amazon.
“I started looking at the hospital grade and the pricing was ridiculous so I ended up choosing the Spectra, which turned out to be the best decision ever. The first night she used it she got out four ounces in 20 minutes. I was so impressed and she stated that it did not hurt unlike manual pumping or the Ameda.Thank you so much for producing such a great product.” – Willy Martinez on Amazon.
“I love this pump! It is quiet and quick. I have never had a whole lot of luck with pumping milk, but with this pump, I have no trouble at all. I will recommend this pump to all of my pregnant friends. The carry bag and bottle cooler pack are very nice quality as well.” – Bridgette J. on Amazon.
When looking at three top-tier breast pumps from the same brand, it can be difficult to choose which one is best for you. And when you have the S1 Plus and S2 Plus, which are both nearly the same thing, it can get even harder. Then there’s the Spectra 9 Plus and Dew 350 which are almost in a class on their own individually. But when it’s all said and done, the best Spectra pump is the S1 Plus.
The Spectra S1 Plus Breast Pump not only offers portability in the form of an easy to carry a pump and a rechargeable battery, but it also gives you the ability to pump as frequently as needed and in a discreet way. Sure, the Spectra S9 is also portable, but it has a short motor warranty, which takes away from the peace of mind that breast pumping moms all need.
Depending on your needs, you can’t really go wrong with any of Spectra’s electric pumps. But if you need portability, the option to have a built-in rechargeable battery, and long life for your pump, then the Spectra S1 Plus is easily the top option for you. Should you prefer something that uses an outlet, then, of course, the S2 Plus is more likely the better choice for you. And of course, the Spectra Dew 350 is the easiest to clean and care of. But somethings little aspects like that aren’t enough to really make it the best pump, per se. And when looking at the positives and negatives of the Spectra S1 Plus, it’s likely the best option for nearly every mom out there.
- Spectra S1 vs. Spectra S2: The Full Electric Breast Pump Comparison
- Spectra S1 vs Medela Freestyle [UPDATED for 2018]: Which Breast Pump Will Come Out on Top?
- The Top 5 Best Hands Free Pumping Bras You’ll Really Love