Unlike formulations with only FDA approval, most European accredited baby formulas are free of various synthetic ingredients making them both safer and healthier nutritional sources. Two such infant formulas are Kendamil vs Holle.
Nutritionally equal, is the verdict that these two formulas get in terms of protein, carbohydrate, vitamins, and oils. But do the nutrient source and method of obtaining them matter? Why should you mind about probiotics and prebiotics inclusion? Why have lactose and not maltodextrin?
Read on to have these questions and more answered, but first, let’s take a look at the main differences between Kendamil vs Holle.
- 1 Main Differences between Kendamil vs Holle
- 2 Kendamil vs Holle Baby Formula Compared
- 3 Holle
- 4 Kendamil
- 5 Kendamil vs Holle Alternatives
- 6 FAQs
- 7 Final Thoughts
Main Differences between Kendamil vs Holle
The main differences between Kendamil vs Holle are:
- Kendamil doesn’t contain pail oil and uses DHA-rich algal oil, whereas Holle contains organic palm oil.
- Kendamil doesn’t use maltodextrin and uses lactose instead, whereas Holle contains organic maltodextrin (a cheap and harmful lactose substitute)
- Kendamil uses organic whole milk, whereas Holle uses Biodynamic Milk powder.
- Kendamil is certified by the European Commission and British Soil Association, whereas Holle has both European commission and Demeter certification
- Kendamil contains only prebiotics and no probiotics, whereas Holle does not contain either prebiotic or probiotic for any of its formulas
- Kendamil use lactose from cow milk as an energy source, whereas Holle has some formulas containing starch (heavy on the delicate infant digestive system) as a carbohydrate source
Kendamil vs Holle Baby Formula Compared
With both Kendamil vs Holle bearing the necessary approval, having been in the infant formula manufacturing business for a long time, featuring almost similar nutrients and ingredients, one can be torn on which to pick.
That is why we took time to look beyond the reviews, read between the lines, and weigh up much more than the taste and organic ingredients to bring you an objective comparison of more than just a brand, certification, or ingredient. Starting us off is the nutritious Demeter certified holle;
With a range of over 80 products amassed through the decades, all labeled sustainable, wholesome, and natural ingredients, a history of contented consumers, a consistent quality check by both independent and government bodies, a nutritionally balanced formula, and unrivaled commitment to quality, Holle (See Detailed Holle Formula review) is a testament that quality, safety, and nutrition is all that caregivers want. Here is a quick rundown of their minimalist macronutrient content;
Infants require lots of energy to match their high rates of utilization necessary for growth and development. For infants, that energy source is lactose. Why lactose? Simply because their digestive systems have the natural ability to secrete enzyme lactase to oxidize the lactose into glucose for use.
Other than being the main energy source, it aids the absorption of calcium and fats in the gut, as well as maintains a healthy population of gut bacteria. And this could be why the European commission requires a minimum of 30% of carbohydrates to be lactose based in infant formulas.
For Holle, their infant formulas are lactose based with an exception of Holle Goat formulas (read more about Holle Goat formula) that use organic maltodextrin and lactose. The maltodextrin used is a derivative of starch that is relatively tasteless. The flat taste is intentionally settled for so as to help balance the natural sweetness of milk.
Other than balancing the taste, it also thickens the formula making it release energy slower than usual making the infants fuller for longer.
The tissues and cells of infants, just like of grownups, are made up of proteins. For infants, these cells are rapidly developing and they, therefore, require tons of proteins, whose source is breast milk or formula as the case maybe.
Breast milk is the ideal standard, has a whey protein to casein ratio of 60% to 40%. This is so unlike cow’s milk that has casein to whey protein ratio of 80% to 20%.
This high casein content can be particularly difficult for infants as it is more difficult to break down and digest until they are 12 months plus. And unfortunately, casein is the dominant protein in cow’s milk.
And this is why Holle adds whey protein to balance off the protein ratio in the formulas they manufacture. This is to make the formula easy to digest for delicate stomachs. For infants with cow milk allergies, Holle offers a goat milk option that has smaller sized protein molecules that are easier to digest (see our holle goat Vs cow formulas comparison)
Prebiotics & Probiotics
Pre and probiotics naturally occur in breast milk. That means that babies can get them as they suckle or are fed on breast milk. With time (babies are born with a sterile gastrointestinal system) they build up a reservoir full of these good gut bacteria and fiber responsible for a stronger digestive system, and that prevents infections.
For Holle, in line with their simple and short list of ingredients, there is no inclusion of either the pre or probiotic. This is despite the many beneficial effects associated with the bacteria with regard to an immune system enhancement, eczema prevention, and calming of colic.
However, they do provide a list of suggestions of prebiotic and probiotics that you can buy to include in their supplements.
DHA & ARA
The European Commission requires that all formulas made under their certification come pre-packed with DHA, Omega-3 fatty acids. To be more competitive and healthier, infant formulas include ARA in the name of Omega-6 fatty acids.
These two have been shown to bolster the immune system, improve vision, nerve, and brain development too.
That is why, Holle, post 2021, has been including fish-derived DHA in Holle cow milk formulas and algae-derived DHA in Holle goat milk formulas. As evidence of compliance to these guidelines, Holle displays quantities of DHA, alpha-linoleic acid (ALA, an omega-6 fatty acid), and linoleic acid (LA, an Omega-6 fatty acid) on all their products.
Organic and Biodynamic Certification
For any product to be organically certified, it must necessarily adhere to pre-set standards that include but are not limited, no use of synthetic chemicals such as antibiotics, growth hormones, herbicides, pesticides, and fertilizers. Simply put, no harm to the environment in any way.
Biodynamic requires that farmers not only farm in a sustainable way but also give back to the environment. Before they can be certified Biodynamic, they must have consistently and consecutively practiced organic farming for 3 years. After which they then have to renew the Biodynamic certification on an annual basis.
The Biodynamic accrediting body is Demeter, and it will only certify one Biodynamic compliant if there is evidence of animal welfare guarantees, ecosystem preservation, and biodiversity promotion among many other criteria.
The badge of safety Holle infant formulas (See how Holle compares with Topfer and Enfamil) bear therefore, is undoubtedly above question as the entire infant formula production process, from farm to packaging is under microscopic scrutiny (here are more organic formulas).
Main Ingredients of Holle
- Biodynamic skimmed milk
- Organic whey powder (partly demineralized)
- Organic vegetable oils [organic palm oil, organic rapeseed oil, organic sunflower oil]
- Organic maltodextrin
- Biodynamic organic milk powder,
- Calcium carbonate,
- Potassium chloride,
- Sodium chloride,
- Vitamin C
- Vitamin E
- Ferrous lactate
- Zinc sulphate
- Copper sulphate,
- Vitamin A,
- Vitamin B1,
- Vitamin B6,
- Manganese sulphate,
- Potassium iodate,
- Folic acid,
- Vitamin K
- Sodium selenite
- Vitamin D
- Does not contain any soy, granulated sugar, wheat, or peanut ingredients.
- Has no gluten and is GMO free
- Free from any chemical, preservatives, and artificial flavors.
- It is Biodynamic, Demeter, and organic certified.
- It is shelf-stable.
- Contains starch and maltodextrin.
- Uses fish oil in some of its formulas.
Most caregivers are content and feel that Holle does offer value for money as they noted that with Holle, their infants were not constipated, were not fussy, pass stool normally and are not gassy. They are even more impressed with the quick deliveries, comfortable spoon handles and the great taste Holle has.
Those who have registered their disappointment note that Holle lacks both pre and probiotics and that the Holle packaging isn’t that pleasing.
Perfected through the years, approved by generations, used by millions, featuring sustainably sourced ingredients, relying on suppliers who are equally passionate and conscious of the benefits of organic farming, with DHA rich algal oil that is naturally obtained is the guarantee Kendamil sells to its consumers. Here is a preview of what it has for macronutrients (skip to Kendamil benefits here);
The best carbohydrate form is that which mimics the one found in breast milk, and that is lactose. This essential carbohydrate is responsible for the much-needed energy in infants for growth and warding off disease-causing microorganisms.
And that is why Kendamil formulas pre pack (read our Kendamil Review) the best lactose from whole cow milk that are grass-fed. The whole milk is not only an energy source but also serves to maintain the healthy gut flora and fauna in the name of prebiotics and probiotics.
This is one of the essential macronutrients responsible for nourishing babies as well as ensuring that your baby grows. Due to this vital role, it is necessary that your baby gets the most appropriate protein in the ratio and form required. And for Kendamil, that source is whey and casein.
Casein is the dominant protein in both cow and goat milk. But unlike in cow’s milk, casein in goat milk is easy to digest making it ideal for infants with sensitive tummies. For the infants using cow’s milk, Kendamil adds demineralized whey protein, making it easier to be digested by rennin to curd.
Prebiotics and probiotics
Just like other standardized organic formulas, Kendamil includes prebiotics in their formulas. They however exclude probiotics as it is not allowed by the accrediting body in the country of origin, the United Kingdom.
But to still ensure that your baby does not miss out on the benefits of probiotics, Kendamil provides adequate amounts of prebiotics to ensure unchecked growth of naturally occurring probiotics. This ensures that your baby’s immune strong is strong to fight most disease-causing microorganisms, reduce colic and enhance digestion
DHA and ARA
These long polyunsaturated fatty acids are known to bolster the immune system, better nerve functioning, improve vision as well as enhance muscle development. Their addition into infant formula, other than for the benefits aforementioned, is majorly to mimic the breast milk profile of Omega-3 and Omega-6 fatty acids.
Unlike other infant formula using fish-based DHA that is derived using hexane, Kendamil (see differences in kendamil stages)uses decantation to naturally obtain DHA from algae, so that your infant can be free of solvent residuals.
The ultimate goal of any infant formula is to be as similar as possible to breast milk. And to match the fatty acid profile in breast milk, formulas include a blend of palm oils so as to mimic the palmitic acid in breast milk.
The Palmitic acid is known to increase calcium and fat absorption along the digestive system. But unlike palmitic acid, the palm oil, instead of aiding in the absorption, hinders absorption which is a minus. Additionally, it may lead to constipation and reduced sustainable exploitation of natural resources.
That is why Kendamil uses natural full cream cow milk fat (read more on kendamil fats here), which is also an oil, and one that is full of oligo-glyceride. This medium-chain oil has overall effects that are almost if not equal to palmitic acid. Its inclusion reduces constipation, renders the formula more infant digestible, and increases calcium absorption.
Minerals and Vitamins
These groups of macronutrients besides being key in growth, metabolism, and nerve functioning, are also key in boosting your infant against nutritional diseases.
They are however not easily absorbed if not given in the correct forms. That is Kendamil uses their salts, in case of minerals, so as to make them more bioavailable for your infant.
Main Ingredients of Kendamil
- Omega 6 and 3
- Palmitic acid
- Vitamin A
- Organic galacto-oligosaccharide
- Zinc Thiamine
- Vitamin E
- Organic skimmed milk
- Vitamin K
- Sodium citrate
- Vitamin B, B6, and B12.
- Organic whole milk
- Folic acid
- Calcium lactate
- Iron Pyrophosphate
- Magnesium chloride
- Vitamin C
- Organic vegetable oils
- Calcium citrate
- Inositol and choline
- Organic demineralized milk whey protein (whey protein unpacked ) powder
- It is gluten-free
- Uses DHA rich algal oil.
- Does not have palm oil.
- It is soy, fish, corn, and starch-free.
- Does not contain maltodextrin
- It is GMO free
- Is free of artificial flavors, preservatives, and chemicals.
- Lacks probiotics.
Many of those who have used Kendamil seem to agree on many things including that it is easy on the infant’s stomach, does not leave infants constipated, has a great creamy taste, is organic and helps reduce colic.
A few others note that it left their infants with a runny stomach and some snappy rash.
Kendamil vs Holle Alternatives
As a caregiver, it is always good to keep your options open. Just in case your favorite brand runs out of stock, does not reach you on time, or they even upgrade and end up adding an ingredient that does not sit well with your infant’s tummy. If that or any other any other unfortunate thing happens, here are other great brands you can try;
If you need your baby to get a taste of the purest, most nutritious, organic, and healthiest baby formula, you need to try Lebenswert.
It is certified by the most stringent independent and government quality checks. Is compliant with all guiding organic and pediatric rules. Practices humane treatment of animals. Is free of any synthetic preservatives or additives and is reliant on past experience that is expertly married with recent research. All these, in an effort to afford your baby the most nutritious Lebenswert formula.
Lebenswert has a healthy balance of vitamins and bioavailable minerals to nourish your baby and boost the infants immune. Uses lactose from cow milk to give your baby energy and fuel the growth of healthy probiotics. Easy to digest proteins to replenish diminishing reserves and replace worn-out cells.
A careful blend of Omega 3 and 6 fatty acids that mimic the breast milk profile that are meant to aid both calcium and fat absorption, as well as reduce colic. This is in addition to pre-tested tiers of formulas that grow with your child. Check our detailed Lebenswert review here or proceed to buy it here.
Bobbie organic infant formula
Intrigued by all the European certified organic formulas but still want a formula that is closer home, is compliant with FDA guidelines, made by parents for parents, informed by research and experience? Try Bobbie organic infant formula
Made to rival, if not outdo, European produced formulas with all the right and most essential of ingredients including DHA and ARA, balanced casein to whey ratio just as in breast milk, non-GMO, free of added sugars and preservatives, and of course a shelf-stable can is what Bobbie organic infant formula is all about. Try it out here and drop us a comment in the comments section below.
Answer: Yes; the formulas are nutritionally equivalent; that is they are produced to mimic breast milk. So they generally contain the same nutrient profile in terms of protein, fats, vitamins, carbohydrates among others. The only difference is the composition of the nutrients, their source, the form used and quantity added.
Answer: Yes. They both contain goat milk-based formulations that can be used by vegetarians and infants with sensitive tummies. Additionally, both of these special formulas do not use fish oil which is a natural allergen.
One of the greatest hurdles for a new mother is choosing the best formula. Just like other caregivers before them, they want a formula that will give their infants all the essential nutrients necessary for their brain, and body requirements without upsetting their little tummies.
This treacherous search is even more arduous if you prefer an organic lifestyle. But thankfully, Kendamil vs Holle have heard your request and come to your aid with the most organic formulas that are not only nutritious and organic but environmentally friendly.