Baby Feeding

Similac Spit Up vs Enfamil AR – Help Babies with Reflux!

Last Updated on

Watching your baby struggle with reflux can be one of the most disheartening experiences of being a parent. Luckily, there are formulas designed specifically for use with infants who have reflux.

They work to quell the frequent spit-up and pain that comes from reflux and will help you and your baby feel better. Similac Spit Up and Enfamil AR are two of the most popular formulas for helping babies with reflux.

Enfamil A.R. Infant Formula - Slightly on Top
$27.48 ($1.28 / Ounce)

Even though BOTH options are great we chose the Enfamil Baby Formula as a slightly better option which is ideal for babies who are otherwise healthy, whereas Similac would be better for babies that have health or other developmental issues.

We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
08/12/2020 10:35 pm

Main Differences Between Similac Spit Up and Enfamil AR

The main differences between Similac Spit Up and Enfamil AR are:

  • Similac Spit Up has added nutrients like DHA, lutein and vitamin E, whereas Enfamil AR has vegetable oils and probiotics.
  • Similac Spit Up only comes in a powder, whereas Enfamil AR comes in both liquid and powder forms
  • Similac Spit Up blend of ingredients is better for babies who have a wide range of health issues, whereas Enfamil AR is a great choice for babies who have reflux but are otherwise healthy

About Reflux

Reflux is a digestive condition where food re-enters the esophagus from the stomach. It happens in all ages but is especially common for babies because their esophageal diaphragm (the mechanism that holds food in the stomach after it’s already passed through the esophagus) is not yet fully developed.

Because babies spend the majority of their time lying flat on their back, gravity can’t help to keep food down like it might in an adult or a child who can already sit up on their own.

As food passes back up into the esophagus from the stomach, it brings with it stomach acid, which causes a burning sensation that can be very uncomfortable. This is what you may be experiencing when you feel heartburn. For babies, it’s agonizing.

As you might expect, when food comes back up the esophagus, it can cause excessive spit up or vomiting. It also means your baby isn’t absorbing the nutrients they need and can lead to poor weight gain as well as other health issues.

While spitting up in infants is common, reflux typically peaks at around four months of age and one of the most common signs that your baby has reflux is spit-up coming out both the mouth and the nose.

How the Right Formula Can Help With Reflux

Formulas designed to help with reflux are much thicker than breastmilk or other infant formulas. This thick consistency is much like a milkshake, and it makes it harder for the food to re-enter the esophagus because it’s too thick.

While it’s still possible, it does so in much smaller quantities. It also contains additional nutrients that your baby needs to maintain proper weight gain. Your baby will keep more of his food down and absorb more of the nutrients he needs to develop.

While there are also medications that can help infants who have reflux, these are often only used in extreme cases or when formula alone doesn’t help. Always consult your baby’s doctor if you feel like he or she needs more than a formula to alleviate the issue.

Similac Spit Up

Similac Spit Up is specially designed to reduce spit-up and aid with reflux because it’s thicker than most other formulas. Similac offers a regular Spit Up formula and a non-GMO Spit Up alternative, although the non-GMO version is not available in all countries.

Similac Spit Up is made with extra vitamin E, lutein, and DHA, giving your child an added dose of the nutrients they may need, especially if they’ve struggled to gain weight due to excessive spitting up.

While every child responds differently to every formula, the parent reviews of Similac Spit Up are overwhelmingly positive, which should give you confidence that it is likely to work, even for your fussy baby.

Does Enfamil AR cause gas?

A lot of infant formulas cause gas because they form bubbles as you mix them. As your baby swallows air, it gets trapped in his stomach and causes uncomfortable gas. The same is true for Enfamil AR, especially because it’s so thick. While Enfamil AR can cause gas, typically these issues are few and far between, compared to the frequent spitting up that you have to deal with when your baby has reflux. If gas is already a problem for your baby, Enfamil AR may not be the right solution. Instead, you can try Enfamil Gentlease, which is designed to be easier to digest and will help alleviate the problems your baby has with gas and excessive crying.

Is Similac Spit Up the same as Enfamil AR?

While these formulas are very similar and are used to treat similar issues, the ingredients vary slightly. Similac Spit Up contains corn syrup as a source of carbohydrates while Enfamil AR uses lactose. Similac Spit Up uses nonfat milk as the protein source while Enfamil AR uses milk protein isolate.

Which is better, Similac, or Enfamil?

For the most part, Enfamil products are better for otherwise healthy babies. However, Similac shines when it comes to immune concerns and other select health issues. When it comes to a baby with reflux, which one you choose is largely dependent on whether or not your baby has other health issues or which ingredient list you prefer.

Can newborns have Enfamil AR?

Yes, your newborn can have Enfamil AR, because it’s designed for infants twelve months of age or younger. You can even start them on it immediately after they’re born if you anticipate problems with reflux, although it’s not common until around four months of age.

Can you switch back and forth between formulas?

Yes, as long as you follow the proper dosing instructions, it shouldn’t hurt your baby to switch from one to the other, or back again. Many new moms like to clip coupons or buy what’s on sale this week, so if you want to switch the brand of formula your baby uses on a whim, you can.

Does Enfamil AR cause weight gain?

Weight loss is common for babies with reflux because they spit up so much that they don’t absorb any of the nutrients in their food. The idea behind a formula designed for babies with reflux is that they’ll be able to keep it down easier and absorb what they need. Enfamil AR and Similac Spit Up both contain additional nutrients that are designed to not only help with reflux but help your baby maintain healthy weight gain.

How do I know if the formula is hurting my baby’s stomach?

Reflux is typically not caused by an upset stomach. Babies with upset stomachs have different issues like excessive gas or colic. However, reflux can be very painful and dangerous if it’s not treated. Signs that your baby has an upset stomach due to his current formula include:

  • Excessive crying or fussiness
  • Not eating or sleeping well
  • Wiggling, squirming or arching his back
  • Vomiting
  • Diarrhea Always consult your baby’s doctor if you think there’s a problem.

Switching to a gentle formula may help. If you notice vomit coming out of both the mouth and the nose, you’re likely dealing with reflux, and a change in formula can help with that, too.

The Verdict

Similac and Enfamil are both very common formula brands and they offer a wide range of quality formula varieties. Both Similac Spit Up and Enfamil AR are great solutions for babies who struggle with reflux.

 

Pay attention to the additives if you’re particular about what your baby eats because they’re both different, but both formulas use rice starch to thicken the powder and aid in reducing symptoms of reflux.

While Enfamil is generally the better choice for babies who are otherwise healthy, Similac can be the right choice for babies who have other health or developmental issues that need additional nutrients.

Switching to a formula that helps with reflux will make you and your baby feel better. You’ll have a happier, healthier baby very soon.

Enfamil A.R. Infant Formula - Slightly on Top
$27.48 ($1.28 / Ounce)

Even though BOTH options are great we chose the Enfamil Baby Formula as a slightly better option which is ideal for babies who are otherwise healthy, whereas Similac would be better for babies that have health or other developmental issues.

We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
08/12/2020 10:35 pm

Main ingredients

The main ingredient in Similac Spit Up to increase the thickness of the formula is rice starch. There’s some disagreement among experts as to whether rice starch is the best way to add thickness to a formula, especially because it adds calories without much nutritional value.

However, rich starch is much safer than manually adding rice cereal, which is what some parents still do to thicken up their baby’s formula.

Similac Spit Up also adds corn syrup as an excellent source of carbohydrates and milk protein isolate as a source of protein. It also has increased amounts of vitamin E, DHA, and lutein over other Similac formulas.

Forms

While many formulas come in both a liquid and a powder, Similac Spit only comes in powder form. Although it comes in a couple of different sizes, you’ll miss out on the portability of premixed liquid and you’ll also miss out on the pre-measured packets that are so convenient for traveling.

The powder is more cost efficient because the tubs of powder last longer than liquid, so the Similac Spit Up is advantageous in that way. However, mixing powder can lead to bubbles, which can lead to gas, giving your infant more tummy troubles than you might be willing to deal with.

Similac For Spit-Up Formula
$28.49 ($1.26 / Ounce)
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
08/12/2020 10:35 pm

Enfamil AR

Enfamil AR is another formula designed to help with reflux because it’s thicker. It’s rich in nutrients to help your child gain weight and there are no added artificial ingredients or flavors.

Enfamil AR is a great solution without empty calories, and they claim that it can reduce spit-up by 50%, but your results may vary. Enfamil also touts a less fussy baby in within 24 hours.

Main ingredients

Enfamil AR also uses rice starch to thicken the formula and it has calcium carbonate just like Similac Spit Up. However, Enfamil AR also adds vegetable oils like sunflower, soy, coconut, and palm.

Enfamil AR also has several different probiotics to aid in healthy digestion. This formula has everything your infant needs and can help them gain weight if they’ve struggled to maintain a healthy weight due to excessive spit-up.

Enfamil AR

Forms

The great thing about Enfamil AR is that it comes in both liquid and powder form as well as several different sizes. You can get individual serving sizes of 2 ounces in the liquid form while the powder comes in tubs and packets.

Liquid is a convenient solution for babies on the go because you don’t have to worry about mixing it up. These premixed bottles are easy to grab and feed at room temperature while convenient sizes make for very little waste.

Premixed liquid also reduces or eliminates extra bubbling and foaming that comes from mixing the powder.

While liquid is more convenient, powder is more affordable. Due to the thicker nature of the formula, it does bubble and foam quite a bit when mixing, which can lead to gas. It comes in plastic tubs and large tins.

Enfamil AR also offers packets of pre-measured formula that are easy to mix in with a bottle of water if you’re traveling or need a portable solution for the diaper bag.

Always follow the appropriate ratio of water to powder when mixing to give your child the correct amount of nutrients as well as the right consistency.

Enfamil A.R. Infant Formula - Slightly on Top
$27.48 ($1.28 / Ounce)

Even though BOTH options are great we chose the Enfamil Baby Formula as a slightly better option which is ideal for babies who are otherwise healthy, whereas Similac would be better for babies that have health or other developmental issues.

We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
08/12/2020 10:35 pm

Alternatives

Similac and Enfamil are both great options and some of the most popular formula brands available. Many parents choose a formula like Similac Spit Up or Enfamil AR, even if their child doesn’t have reflux, because they have so many extra nutrients.

However, there are some others you can try if these don’t work for you or you feel like reflux isn’t what you’re struggling with.

Gerber

Gerber is known for all of their quality baby products, and their formula is no different. They have a variety that’s made for infants who have digestive issues, called Good Start SoothePro.

Gerber designed this product to be more like Enfamil Gentlease or Similac Sensitive. It has a special blend of simple proteins for babies who struggle with gas, colic, or excessive fussiness, but is not designed to be thick like Similac Spit Up or Enfamil AR.

Gerber Good Start Soothe
$24.99 ($1.29 / Ounce)
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
08/12/2020 07:34 pm

Similac

Similac offers several other varieties for sensitive stomachs including Pro-Total Comfort, Pro-Sensitive, and Sensitive.

Similac Pro-Total Comfort is a lot like Enfamil Gentlease. The proteins have been partially broken down so they can be digested easier and it’s great for babies who have gas. Similac says that your baby will be less fussy within 24 hours.

Similac Pro-Sensitive and Sensitive formulas contain a blend of ingredients that support better eye and brain development. It also has 2’-FL HMO for immune support, which is a common ingredient in breastmilk.

OUR TOP CHOICE: Similac Pro Sensitive
$116.00 ($1.11 / Ounce)
The Similac Pro Sensitive formula is out top choice because it's made of non-GMO ingredients, it's safe to be consumed by infants from their first day and because it boosts the immune system.
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
08/12/2020 07:34 pm

Enfamil

enfamil neuropro sensitive

Enfamil also offers other gentle products like Gentlease and their line of NeuroPro formulas with added ingredients for brain and eye development. Gentlease has simple proteins that have already been broken down for easier digestion.

The NeuroPro Sensitive formula is designed for use in infants from birth to three months old.

We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
08/13/2020 03:34 am

FAQ

If your baby has a sensitive stomach or reflux, you may be looking for the right formula to help them feel better. These frequently asked questions can help you decide which variety will be best for your infant.

Does Enfamil AR cause gas?

A lot of infant formulas cause gas because they form bubbles as you mix them. As your baby swallows air, it gets trapped in his stomach and causes uncomfortable gas. The same is true for Enfamil AR, especially because it’s so thick. While Enfamil AR can cause gas, typically these issues are few and far between, compared to the frequent spitting up that you have to deal with when your baby has reflux. If gas is already a problem for your baby, Enfamil AR may not be the right solution. Instead, you can try Enfamil Gentlease, which is designed to be easier to digest and will help alleviate the problems your baby has with gas and excessive crying.

Is Similac Spit Up the same as Enfamil AR?

While these formulas are very similar and are used to treat similar issues, the ingredients vary slightly. Similac Spit Up contains corn syrup as a source of carbohydrates while Enfamil AR uses lactose. Similac Spit Up uses nonfat milk as the protein source while Enfamil AR uses milk protein isolate.

Which is better, Similac, or Enfamil?

For the most part, Enfamil products are better for otherwise healthy babies. However, Similac shines when it comes to immune concerns and other select health issues. When it comes to a baby with reflux, which one you choose is largely dependent on whether or not your baby has other health issues or which ingredient list you prefer.

Can newborns have Enfamil AR?

Yes, your newborn can have Enfamil AR, because it’s designed for infants twelve months of age or younger. You can even start them on it immediately after they’re born if you anticipate problems with reflux, although it’s not common until around four months of age.

Can you switch back and forth between formulas?

Yes, as long as you follow the proper dosing instructions, it shouldn’t hurt your baby to switch from one to the other, or back again. Many new moms like to clip coupons or buy what’s on sale this week, so if you want to switch the brand of formula your baby uses on a whim, you can.

Does Enfamil AR cause weight gain?

Weight loss is common for babies with reflux because they spit up so much that they don’t absorb any of the nutrients in their food. The idea behind a formula designed for babies with reflux is that they’ll be able to keep it down easier and absorb what they need. Enfamil AR and Similac Spit Up both contain additional nutrients that are designed to not only help with reflux but help your baby maintain healthy weight gain.

How do I know if the formula is hurting my baby’s stomach?

Reflux is typically not caused by an upset stomach. Babies with upset stomachs have different issues like excessive gas or colic. However, reflux can be very painful and dangerous if it’s not treated. Signs that your baby has an upset stomach due to his current formula include:

  • Excessive crying or fussiness
  • Not eating or sleeping well
  • Wiggling, squirming or arching his back
  • Vomiting
  • Diarrhea Always consult your baby’s doctor if you think there’s a problem.

Switching to a gentle formula may help. If you notice vomit coming out of both the mouth and the nose, you’re likely dealing with reflux, and a change in formula can help with that, too.

The Verdict

Similac and Enfamil are both very common formula brands and they offer a wide range of quality formula varieties. Both Similac Spit Up and Enfamil AR are great solutions for babies who struggle with reflux.

 

Pay attention to the additives if you’re particular about what your baby eats because they’re both different, but both formulas use rice starch to thicken the powder and aid in reducing symptoms of reflux.

While Enfamil is generally the better choice for babies who are otherwise healthy, Similac can be the right choice for babies who have other health or developmental issues that need additional nutrients.

Switching to a formula that helps with reflux will make you and your baby feel better. You’ll have a happier, healthier baby very soon.

Enfamil A.R. Infant Formula - Slightly on Top
$27.48 ($1.28 / Ounce)

Even though BOTH options are great we chose the Enfamil Baby Formula as a slightly better option which is ideal for babies who are otherwise healthy, whereas Similac would be better for babies that have health or other developmental issues.

We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
08/12/2020 10:35 pm

Leave a Reply