Baby Feeding

Similac Sensitive vs Pro Sensitive: Which is Best for Your Baby?

Last Updated on

If your infant deals with fussiness or gassiness, then both Similac Sensitive and the Pro Sensitive formula are good for these specific issues. Still, they are different in several aspects that we will discuss in more detail in today’s comparative review. In terms of nutritional values, these baby formulas are pretty similar. However, the difference comes from the carb content.

Below, you will discover some other important differences as well as similarities that these two baby formulas have.

OUR TOP CHOICE: Similac Pro Sensitive
The Similac Pro Sensitive formula is out top choice because it's made of non-GMO ingredients, it's safe to be consumed by infants from their first day and because it boosts the immune system.
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

The Main Differences Between Similac Sensitive and Pro Sensitive

  • Similac Sensitive contains standard ingredients, whereas the Pro Sensitive option also features a special blend of probiotics;
  • Similac Sensitive provides a few more percentages of lactose, whereas Pro Sensitive alternative contains a lower amount of lactose (less than 2%)
  • Similac Sensitive contains more sugar and a higher amount of carbs, whereas Pro Sensitive has fewer carbohydrates;
  • Similac Sensitive might include some genetically-modified compounds, whereas Pro Sensitive is manufactured with non-GMO ingredients
  • Similac Sensitive has a higher price tag, whereas Pro Sensitive is more affordable

Similac Sensitive vs Pro Sensitive – What Are They?

Similac Sensitive

This infant formula was created for babies who have sensitive tummies, and some even say that it can work for those with galactosemia which is a kind of lactose intolerance. Still, make sure you ask your baby’s doctor if it is alright to use it in cases of certain health conditions. After all, the company claims that this formula is effective in those circumstances but doctors haven’t confirmed this aspect yet.

According to the manufacturer, this product should lower excessive fussiness in those babies who are incompatible with other formulas. Although the ideal situation is the one in which a new mom is able to breastfeed her little one, Similac Sensitive is quite complete from a nutritional point of view.

We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

Similac Pro Sensitive

Mead Johnson is the one who created this infant formula. It is pretty similar to the Similac Sensitive version but its ingredient profile is quite different. Unlike the standard formula, the Similac Pro Sensitive version has no artificial growth hormones. For that reason, it is called a non-GMO formula.

The formula’s main purpose is the same as the one that Similac Sensitive has: to lower uncomfortable sensations in your baby’s tummy.

OUR TOP CHOICE: Similac Pro Sensitive
The Similac Pro Sensitive formula is out top choice because it's made of non-GMO ingredients, it's safe to be consumed by infants from their first day and because it boosts the immune system.
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

Similac Sensitive vs Pro Sensitive – Ingredients

Similac Sensitive

Similac Sensitive contains milk-based ingredients. It was designed to lower fussiness but the providing company did mention that this product isn’t meant to work as a formula replacement for babies with mild digestive system problems.

It contains a special blend of lutein, DHA, and vitamin E. This mix leads to a healthy sight and proper brain development. Here are some of the main ingredients included in this formula:

  • Corn syrup;
  • Sugar;
  • Milk protein isolate;
  • Coconut oil;
  • High oleic safflower oil;
  • Soy oil;
  • Vitamins – A, K, D, E, B1, B6, B2, C;
  • Minerals – calcium, magnesium, zinc, potassium, iron, etc.

Similac Pro Sensitive

The Similac Pro Sensitive formula is the company’s upgraded version, the one that doesn’t contain any artificial growth hormones. Just like the other Similac formula, this one also contains a mix of lutein, DHA, and vitamin E. All these ingredients are great for both brain and eye development.

This upgraded formula also comes with a healthy dose of 2’-FL HMO which is a great compound that supports your baby’s immune system. Here are some of the product’s other important ingredients:

  • Corn syrup;
  • Soy oil;
  • Milk protein isolate;
  • Sugar;
  • Coconut oil;
  • High oleic safflower oil;
  • Taurine;
  • Vitamins – A, B, C, D, K, etc.;
  • Minerals – magnesium, potassium, phosphorus, calcium, etc.

Similac Sensitive vs Pro Sensitive – Nutritional Value

Similac Sensitive Nutritional Information – per 5.3 fluid ounces (serving size)

Calories 100
Protein 2.1 g
Carbohydrates 11.1 g
Fat 5.4 g
Linoleic acid 1000 mg
Water 140 g
Calcium 88 mg
Magnesium 6 mg

Similac Pro Sensitive Nutritional Information

Calories 100
Protein 2.1 g
Carbohydrates 10.9 g
Fat 5.4 g
Linoleic acid 1000 mg
Water 141 g
Calcium 88 mg
Magnesium 6 mg

Similac Sensitive vs Pro Sensitive – Pros and Cons

Similac Sensitive Advantages

  • It has a pretty good nutritional value;
  • It is an affordable infant formula;
  • This formula is effective when it comes to alleviating fussiness in infants;
  • It is easy to prepare and use;
  • You can choose from a wide range of forms and sizes.

Similac Sensitive Disadvantages

  • It lacks probiotics;
  • It is more affordable than Similac Pro Sensitive but some parents still consider it a tad on the pricey side;
  • May cause constipation;
  • It may have a strong taste that your child could reject.

Similac Pro Sensitive Advantages

  • It is a non-GMO product which is safe for your babies;
  • It is free of palm oil;
  • This formula comes with a healthy dose of calcium that supports strong bones;
  • It also contains prebiotics which ensures a healthy digestive system;
  • Besides being non-GMO, this product is also gluten-free.

Similac Pro Sensitive Disadvantages

  • It is more expensive than the Similac Sensitive formula;
  • According to some people, this formula shouldn’t be used for babies with galactosemia;
  • It seems that this formula creates too much foam when it is prepared.

Similac Sensitive vs Pro Sensitive – Taste

Compared to other types of formulas, the Similac Sensitive option comes with a pretty strong odor and quite a powerful taste. It is up to new moms, but more importantly, up to their newborn babies to decide whether or not they appreciate this product’s taste. While some infants don’t seem to mind the formula’s odor, others might reject it.

Meanwhile, it appears that Similac Pro Sensitive has a milder taste without missing an overtone of sweetness. It has a sweet taste and a creamy texture which aren’t bad. Nevertheless, some babies might need a few moments to get used to this product’s taste.

Similac Sensitive vs Pro Sensitive – Price

Similac Sensitive is an affordable baby formula. Its price is quite similar to the one of Similac Advance. Although there are other formulas out there that are marketed at even lower prices, many parents would rather opt for the name brand formula which is totally understandable.

Similac Pro Sensitive is sold at a higher price than Similac Sensitive because of its non-GMO ingredients. It is a premium product, made of safe and high-quality ingredients that are also very nutritious, so the price could be somehow justified.

Similac Sensitive vs Pro Sensitive – Customer Ratings

Similac Sensitive

Similac Sensitive has a rating of 4.1 stars out of a total of 5. More than 60% of the reviewers have given it 5 stars and only 13% of the customers have rated the product with one star.

Most people are pleased with this infant formula, saying it is a good one that’s effective and easy to prepare. A few complained about its bad taste and said that the texture is a tad thick.

Similac Pro Sensitive

The Pro Sensitive version has received 4.5 out of a total of 5 stars. Almost 80% of all customers have given this product a rating of 5 stars while only 7% have rated the formula with one star.

Most clients praise this formula, saying it is good and effective. On the other hand, there are a few people who said that the pull-tab design is poorly made. Also, they are not happy with how much foam this formula makes when they shake it in order to prepare it.

Similac Sensitive vs Pro Sensitive – Main Alternatives

two babies lying on teal textile

Both Sensitive and Pro Sensitive formulas made by Similac are great for fussiness and gassiness in babies. But there are other good options on the market that could also do the trick when it comes to upset tummies. Here are some of these alternatives:

  • Gerber Gentle baby formula – its ingredients don’t cause constipation. This formula’s ingredient profile promotes a healthy development of the nervous system. Gerber Gentle has a pleasant taste and will help your baby produce softer stools;
  • Gerber Soothe infant formula – this formula comes with non-GMO ingredients and contains HMO which boosts immunity while also promoting a healthy digestive system. Due to its probiotic content, this formula alleviates symptoms such as fussiness, gas, bloating, tummy pain, and crying;
  • Enfamil Nutramigen infant formula – this is a great choice for babies who don’t tolerate cow milk. It is a nutritionally-balanced formula and its proteins are hydrolyzed which makes them easy to digest;
  • Earth’s Best Sensitive formula – it comes with all the essential nutrients, vitamins, and minerals that support your little one’s overall health and proper development. It contains a low amount of lactose and it is a certified organic baby formula.

FAQs About Similac Sensitive vs Pro Sensitive

Do You Need to Give Sensitive Formula to Your Infant?

If your little one struggles with issues such as excessive gas, fussiness, and diarrhea, you should consider replacing its formula. Many times, these problems have something to do with formulas but, in case these symptoms don’t go away, even after you try another product, you should definitely see your pediatrician.

What Kind of Water Works Best to Prepare a Newborn Formula?

Any water will do, as long as it’s clean. Tap water should be boiled for a minute to make sure any bacteria get killed. Then, cool it down till it reaches room temperature. Ideally, you could use bottled water; one that contains a low level of fluoride.

Do You Need to Warm the Formula Before Giving It to Your Baby?

You don’t necessarily have to warm the formula. The water can be warm if you choose to use tap water and boil it before adding the liquid to prepare the formula. Otherwise, you can also use cold water but make sure that it reaches room temperature for your child’s well-being.

What Is the 2′-FL HMO that the Similac Pro Sensitive Formula Contains?

The HMO initials stand for human milk oligosaccharides. This is an immune-nourishing prebiotic that’s also found in breast milk. It promotes a healthy immune system.

Can Similac Formulas Cause Diarrhea?

No, it appears that all Similac products for babies don’t cause diarrhea but they might cause constipation although this isn’t a commonly-met issue. They are sensitive formulas that work well on upset tummies. These products were specially made for lactose-intolerant babies.

OUR TOP CHOICE: Similac Pro Sensitive
The Similac Pro Sensitive formula is out top choice because it's made of non-GMO ingredients, it's safe to be consumed by infants from their first day and because it boosts the immune system.
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

Similac Sensitive vs Pro Sensitive – Final Thoughts

These formulas are both good for most infants. They are very similar in many aspects. Still, in the end, the thing that matters the most is how well your child approves of it and if his or her body adjusts well to these products’ ingredients. I, for one, would opt for the Pro Sensitive version due to its non-GMO ingredients.

I hope that by now, you have clarified most of your uncertainties and you are now ready to make a purchasing decision; one that suits your child best.

Recommended Reads:

Leave a Reply