Skip to Content

Naturepedic Crib Mattress Review – Why I LOVE It

Naturepedic Crib Mattress Review – Why I LOVE It

Organic crib mattresses are gaining popularity these days because of a growing concern with chemicals in traditional mattresses. Studies have linked these mattress chemicals to certain childhood disorders and physicians, public safety officials, environmental advocacy groups, and other health professionals have started recommending organic more.

Naturepedic makes three different organic crib mattresses and promises an excellent baby mattress that has a non-toxic design made with natural and organic materials. It’s also fire resistant and can increase your baby’s overall health and safety.

About Naturepedic

Naturepedic makes crib, toddler, and adult mattresses, as well as changing pads, protector pads, and crib sheets. Everything is 100% organic for your comfort and peace of mind. They’re manufactured for lasting quality.

Naturepedic believes that Mother Nature makes the best materials for healthy mattresses and comfortable sleeping. They offer your child a healthy sleeping environment with the help of pediatricians, chemists, and engineers. They’re made by Amish craftsmen in a GOTS-certified factory in Ohio.

Mattress Options

While Naturepedic offers three different mattresses, the basic Naturepedic mattress is called the Classic. It comes with a wipe-clean waterproof surface, lightweight or 150 coil support, and a single or dual stage firmness.

You can upgrade to the Breathable mattress for a removable washable breathable surface with the same waterproof backing, lightweight or 252 coil support, and dual-stage firmness. The Breathable Ultra has a thicker, quilted removable surface made of designer fabric.

No matter which you choose, the basic mattress construction is the same. It’s a durable mattress that uses organic cotton instead of the synthetic fabrics and foams found in traditional mattresses.

All of their cottons is grown in the U.S. and certified organic. Naturepedic buys their cotton from USDA-certified sources so they can track organic reliability and purity. They test their mattresses for chemical emissions and include a bed bug and dust mite barrier.


Naturepedic mattresses come in a plain cardboard box, so it’s nothing to write home about. But once you open it up, you’ll see the Naturepedic stickers and the informational pamphlet. On the pamphlet, you’ll find everything you need to know about your new crib mattress. They’ve also included certification stickers to assure you of its organic status.

Features and Benefits

Naturepedic mattresses have plenty of great features that offer a ton of benefits for your child. We’ve only just scratched the surface. These features set it apart from so many others, even those that are also organic.

The research Naturepedic has done in order to design this mattress includes scientific discoveries that help to build the best mattress possible. They have earned more awards and endorsements than any other company making children’s mattresses. They also offer the best warranty of any other crib mattress.


First of all, the mattress is made with certified organic cotton. The cotton is grown without fertilizers, synthetic pesticides, or genetically modified organisms. They use only the best U.S. grown organic filling. It’s a great alternative to foam, which is chemically treated, or latex, which is allergy-prone.

The food-grade polyethylene they use for their waterproof surfaces is the type of plastic used to package food. It has pure, non-toxic properties that make it safer than other plastics. It’s specially formulated to meet standards for food contact.

This type of plastic is very resistant to stains and easy to clean while creating a barrier for dust mites, bed bugs, and other allergens at the same time.

The steel inner springs are made from heavy-duty, high-quality steel to provide the ultimate support without contributing to any other allergies or health concerns. The 150-coil mattress has 13 gauge coils with a 9 gauge border wire. The 252-coil mattresses have even more durability and support.

Non-GMO potato starch PLA comprises the fibers of the mattress. It’s made entirely of plants and doesn’t contain harmful chemicals or give off any gas. It’s a material that’s commonly used in food packaging and biomedical applications like sutures and stents.

Naturepedic has eliminated the need for fire retardant chemicals in their mattresses because organic cotton is much less flammable than mattresses that contain harmful chemicals. Their mattresses meet all federal and state flammability standards without extra additives.


Naturepedic offers superior comfort because the inner springs are designed to offer superior durability while balancing firm support with a bit of bounce. It’s important for a baby to have the right amount of support to help with development.

Rather than feeling like a rock, it has just the right amount of give so they can rest comfortably on a soft surface. The thicker quilting of the Breathable Ultra mattress enhances this comfort and choosing any of the mattresses with the 2-stage dual firmness will help, too.


The unique thing about the 2-stage dual firmness is that you can place your infant on the firm side while they’re developing and then put them on the softer side as a toddler. It’s like two mattresses in one, giving them just the right amount of support for that stage of life.

It falls in line with the Consumer Product Safety Commission recommendations for firmness and is safe for both babies and toddlers. The 150 coils innerspring design offers a firm, flat surface that supports rolling without sinking.

The edge support is also beyond compare. When in a crib, proper edge support prevents sinking at the edges and keeps your baby from getting stuck between the mattress and the crib rails.

As a toddler, your child won’t have rails, so this edge support does a great job of keeping them on the mattress when they roll, rather than sinking at the edges and pitching them off onto the floor.

The edges are lined with coils to keep them firm. Pressing down on the edge with all of your adult weight will reveal just how firm they are.

Corner Design

Most crib mattresses feature rounded corners. These mattresses often don’t fit right in the crib, creating a sliding or a gap issue that could cause your child to get stuck or suffocate. Naturepedic mattresses have square corners without seams.

They fit more securely in most cribs without any extra movement. Without seams, the corners are quite soft, so they won’t be sharp to the touch if your child does migrate that way as they’re sleeping.

The lack of seams also means the fabric on the mattress won’t unravel. It won’t give your child anything to grab onto or fidget with. This just adds to its extreme durability.


Thanks to this extreme durability, this mattress is very heavy. It makes for some extra work when you have sheet changes in the middle of the night. Unfortunately, there’s no way around it. However, for most parents, it’s a great trade-off for the durability, comfort, and ease of cleaning.


While the Naturepedic mattresses are simply spectacular, they are a bit pricey. It really does make it worth it because it’s going to last your child well through their toddler years and you can likely use it for your next child as well.

However, if you’re looking for some alternatives so you can shop around and get the best mattress for you, there are a few other great ones out there.

Newton Wovenaire

The Newton Wovenaire mattress is another organic mattress that’s comparable in price to the Naturepedic options. The unique thing about this mattress is that it’s 100% washable. You can take the water-resistant cover off and machine wash it, but you can also throw the entire mattress in the tub and wash it.

That makes it worth it for those times when you find spilled milk, leaky diapers, or middle of the night sickness that leaves sweat, vomit, and other icky things soaked through.

Moonlight Slumber Starlight Simplicity

It’s a mouthful, and it’s pretty expensive, but for those who are more environmentally conscious than most, this mattress is not only 100% organic, but it’s 100% recyclable. It offers dual firmness with a breathable design.

The primary difference here is that this mattress does contain some natural latex, although it doesn’t have any harsh chemicals, foam, or other allergens.

Nook Sleep Systems

This company offers three different crib mattresses that are also dual-sided. The Air only weighs 7 pounds, making it pretty easy to lift up if it needs to be changed. The Pure has an organic coconut coir base with natural latex foam.

The Dream has upcycled cotton denim and the Air has non-toxic CertiPUR foam. Both are fused with non-toxic PETE making them breathable and comfortable. All three feature a patented eucalyptus mattress cover so any moisture on the surface beads up for up to 30 minutes, giving you plenty of time to get to it before it soaks through. It’s also easy to remove with a zipper.

The unique thing about this mattress is that it comes in plenty of colors including white, gray, green, pink, blue, and red.


If you’re on the fence about which crib mattress to buy, here are some frequently asked questions that may help you decide.

What is the best Naturepedic crib mattress?

All Naturepedic crib mattresses are excellent. If you want superior comfort and durability, you’ll get that no matter which one you choose. For extra breathability, opt for the Breathable, and for more easy cleaning and plush comfort, get the Breathable Ultra.
However, it will also depend on your budget and how much you have set aside for a crib mattress. The Classic is the most cost-effective option, and you’re still getting a fantastic mattress that will last your child through toddlerhood.

Are Naturepedic mattresses worth it?

It all depends on your perspective. You can pay much less for a crib mattress, but it won’t last as long and you’ll be spending more money on another one before you know it. A lot of mattresses simply aren’t as durable. They don’t offer as much support, and they sink after months of use.
A Naturepedic mattress won’t sink and will hold up for years. It’s also one of the only crib mattresses that’s 100% organic, dual-sided, and seamless. Their commitment to using no chemicals or allergens seems to be stronger than most.

What is the difference between a crib and a toddler mattress?

Believe it or not, crib mattresses and toddler mattresses are the same. Toddler beds are simply cribs without rails, which is why so many cribs are easy to convert to toddler beds by taking the front panel off.
Both types of beds take the same size mattress, making transitions so much easier. The difference is in how you put the child to bed. Babies don’t sleep with any extra sheets, blankets, or pillows.

What are the least toxic mattresses?

Once again, Naturepedic wins out. They are some of the least toxic and hypoallergenic mattresses on the market. While the price might seem high compared to traditional mattresses, they’re actually much cheaper than other all-natural or 100% organic mattresses.

Final Thoughts

In your intense search for the best mattress possible for your little one, you’ve likely read about dozens of different mattresses. The Naturepedic difference is that these mattresses are 100% organic and much more durable than so many others.

The lack of seams means they won’t rip as easily, they offer superior comfort, support, and breathability, and they are cheaper than other organic solutions. Not only that but because it has square corners and firm edges, it’s much safer than other crib mattresses.

It’s worth every penny to give your child a good night’s sleep and ensure that they are safe, comfortable, and able to grow in a healthy way with a supportive mattress.

Further read:

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *