Skip to Content

Colgate Crib Mattress Review: Specifications, Pros and Cons

Colgate Crib Mattress Review: Specifications, Pros and Cons
Latest posts by Keith Lindner (see all)

Our Colgate crib mattress review will hopefully come in handy if you have already purchased a crib for your baby, and you’re now looking to find the perfect mattress.

Quality sleep is essential for a baby’s health and wellbeing, and there are lots of factors to consider when looking into safe sleeping. We have previously provided a highly-detailed guide on purchasing the best baby and toddler crib mattresses, including safety testing information and top tips to aid your search.

This Colgate Crib Mattress review contains everything you’ll need to know, including; the products specifications, company details, pros and cons as well as alternative crib mattresses you might want to consider if you feel the Colgate Crib is not the right option for your baby.

Colgate Crib Mattress
Buy Now
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

Why buy the Colgate crib mattress

Colgate Crib Mattress Review

Colgate is a third-generation, family-owned company that manufactures some of the highest quality crib mattresses in the USA. With a 65 year history, they’re one of the longest-running crib mattress producers out there.

It isn’t just the Colgate family who endorse the product however, look at reviews on consumer sites such as Feefo and you’ll see that genuine consumers have rated the product 5/5.

Specifications of the Colgate Crib Mattress

  • Size: 24” x 38.5” x 3”. Designed to fit standard American portable cribs
  • Weight: 2.8lbs
  • Batteries required:  No
  • Minimum weight restrictions: 1 lb
  • Maximum weight restrictions: 65lbs

Features of the Colgate Crib Mattress

The mattress is handcrafted in the USA using eco-friendly foam that is composed of natural plant oils. No harmful toxins, emissions or chemicals feature in the product, making it a highly safe option for your baby.

With 3 inches of quality thickness a baby is supported during sleep or play. A damask cloth cover means that the baby’s skin will be gently touched instead of being irritated by polyethylene plastic or vinyl.

Underneath the cloth is the waterproof backing, prolonging the life of the mattress and keeping hygiene a top priority.

So, to summarize the features:

  • It is safeCertiPUR-US and Green Guard Gold safe: No harmful emissions or chemicals
  • Material type – Memory foam
  • Comfort – Extra plush comfort with 3” thickness
  • Waterproof – Highly durable and tear-resistant
  • Non-toxic – Hypoallergenic and Phthalate free
  • Lightweight – Making quick work of sheet changes
  • Made in the USA

The Advantages of the Colgate Crib Mattress

portable foam crib mattress

The Colgate crib mattress belongs to one family business that only produces baby products, including the necessary add-ons such as; crib storage bags and organic mattress covers. Their ethos is fundamentally based on the safety of babies, children, and the environment which has earned them many industry awards.


The Colgate crib mattress is designed to fit the vast majority of standard-sized portable cribs. Babies can stay in their cribs at night for up to three years and during that time there will be a lot of changes to the baby’s behavior.

If you have a standard crib mattress, it can transition with ease to the next crib. It also means that if you’re planning a vacation or visiting relatives, you can simply take the mattress and not the entire crib with you – providing there is a standard-sized crib waiting.


With its tear-resistant and waterproof cover, the product is designed with durability in mind. The Colgate crib mattress has a maximum weight restriction of 65lbs which is the average weight of a child aged between 8 and 10 years! So it will certainly be enough for younger children.


There is a lot of misinformation out there about the apparent lack of safety with memory foam crib mattresses. What’s important to consider is that a memory foam mattress created with adult weight in mind is constructed very differently than one with a minimum weight restriction of one pound.

When it comes to baby safety, Colgate has covered every aspect with its innovative, eco-friendly design. Other companies may lay claim to high-breathability within their memory foam mattresses but this could be limited to just the mattress cover. Whereas Colgate uses high-quality, PE, and open-cell foam, with air channels that enhance air circulation.

Environmentally friendly

The mattress creators have recognized their responsibility, in today’s climate, to produce products that are environmentally friendly and are doing this in a number of eco-conscious ways:

  • Energy efficiency – Working with their local Georgia Power who perform energy audits within the factory; looking for any inefficiencies and finding ways to reduce the consumption on the local power grid.
  • Green canopy – Trees Atlanta planted long-lasting hardwoods to enhance Colgate Mattress factory’s green canopy. Founded in 1985, Trees Atlanta has now planted more than 100,000 trees and is committed to expanding natural tree canopies to improve air quality.
  • Recycling – They have reduced the thickness of packaging in order to be more waste efficient and reduce their contribution to landfills. Colgate mattresses are also using as much recycled materials as they possibly can.
  • Reducing local erosion – The Colgate mattress factory is near to the stunning Atlanta Beltline who were battling erosion issues at the time of the factory construction. Colgate donated pallets full of 100% natural scrap coir fiber to be stacked and staked down, providing an eco-friendly and effective solution to erosion control.
  • Using natural materials – They were the very first in the USA to use the spun matrix, 100% recyclable material called Natures Nest. In addition to this, they source eco foam for their mattresses which are made from plant oils.
Colgate Crib Mattress
Buy Now
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

The Disadvantages of Colgate Crib Mattress

colgate portable mattress

Whilst the Colgate crib mattress seems to tick a lot of boxes, there can be some downsides to the product, including:


Within the US Crib mattress lower budget range the Colgate mattress doesn’t come with an ‘ideal’ price tag.

Non-Removable Cover

You cannot remove the waterproof cover, which means it’s not the easiest to clean thoroughly.

Size Confusion

Some customers have mentioned that there’s been confusion with sizing; described as being designed to fit most standard portable American cribs; some brands will be slightly larger, or indeed smaller, than standard size. It is important that you measure your crib precisely before purchasing any mattress.

You shouldn’t be able to fit more than two fingers between the mattress and the crib, as any more than this is potentially dangerous. With over 30 variants of crib styles on the market today, they can differ in size and shape greatly.

Colgate Crib Mattress Alternatives

Here are some other crib mattresses you may want to look into if you feel as though the Colgate Crib mattress is not right for you:

The Newton Crib Mattress

newton crib mattress

The Newton Crib Mattress is the leader of the pack when it comes to breathable crib mattresses. It has great online reviews, no hidden labels, ingredients, or chemicals, and is undoubtedly a safe choice. It is highly breathable, free from toxic fire retardants, and 100% recyclable.

The huge advantage of this mattress is that it is entirely washable too! The downside to this mattress is it is not a budget-friendly option, with prices starting at around $300 and only going up.

Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed
Check Price
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
02/22/2024 02:28 pm GMT

Bubble bear Foam Crib Mattress and Toddler Mattress

Bubble bear Foam Crib Mattress and Toddler Mattress

The Amazon Choice – Bubble bear foam crib mattress complies with, or exceeds, U.S standards for baby mattresses. It is available in different designs, such as; ‘Cute Car’, ‘Dinosaur Kingdom’ and ‘Summer Profusion’, which makes it more visually appealing than a plain white mattress.

Its sturdy edge gives the baby the required stability and support to prevent sinking edges and to promote safe sleeping. It can take up to 72 hours to fully expand, however, so would need purchasing and unpacking before your baby is due home.

Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress

graco premium foam crib ad mattress

The Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress is a very popular mattress. It has been rigorously tested and certified safe – free from phthalates and lead and made using anti-static, anti-microbial substances. This mattress comes with a 6-year manufacturer’s limited warranty and meets flammability standards, set by the federal government.

The fact that it comes in a small box, makes it easy to store and carry. However, that being said the mattress needs to be unrolled and left to fully expand for upto two weeks prior to use.

Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress | Target

This crib and toddler mattress ships compressed in a lightweight box for ultimate convenience; For optimal performance, unroll your mattress within 2 weeks of purchase to allow for proper expansion in a room temperature setting.

Buy at
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

The Colgate Mini Crib Mattress

If you’re restricted with space and are considering purchasing aMini Cribthen you can gain all of the above features of the standard Colgate Crib Mattress with the Colgate Mini Crib Mattress.

Mini cribs have many advantages for prospective parents, even as an additional purchase to a standard-sized crib. It may provide a safe solution to downstairs sleep for the baby so you can keep an eye on them, it could be a simple way to visit relatives or go on vacations as the mini crib is much more portable – often even coming with wheels to aid movability within the home from room to room.


Question: Is the Colgate crib mattress crinkly and noisy when the baby moves?

Answer: Due to the brocade cover and the mattress is made of non-plastic materials, it shouldn’t disturb your baby during movement.

Question: Is the Colgate crib flame and fire retardant?

Answer: Colgate has opted to use non-toxic barrier fabrics, over the more harsh fire retardant chemicals. This provides parents with peace of mind and exceeds federal flammability standards.

Question: How do I keep the Colgate crib clean?

Answer: It’s important to keep an eye on the overall cleanliness of the mattress. Humidity, high-temperatures, and prolonged moisture can bring with it mildew and mold. You should remove any stains you find using mild soap or hypoallergenic laundry detergent and a soft-bristle brush.
Following this, a damp cloth should be applied to take away the excess cleaning product from the mattress. You should towel dry and hang the mattress outside if you’re able, alternatively use a hairdryer on a cool setting for up to 15 minutes. Ensure the mattress is thoroughly dried before putting back into the crib.

Question: Where is the Colgate crib mattress made?

Answer: The mattress is made in Georgia, USA, with Colgate Mattress priding themselves on American integrity, craftsmanship, and ingenuity.

Question: Does the Colgate crib fit all standard cribs?

Answer: No. In order to be certain of the size, you should measure your crib, or look for the measurements online of your desired crib, then compare it to the mattress. A crib mattress should fit within the crib snugly, leaving no gaps for a baby’s arms or legs to become trapped. Remember, if you can fit 2 fingers between the crib mattress and the crib then it is not a compatible pairing.

Final Thoughts – Is the Colgate Crib Mattress Good For You?

If you’re looking for a crib mattress that’s made entirely in the USA by a company that is achieving great things, when it comes to sustainability then it’s worth considering the Colgate crib mattress.

It has many advantages, such as; affordability and company transparency and is manufactured by a baby product manufacturing veteran. If they weren’t good at what they do, would they be approaching their 7th decade in the industry?

The mattress is highly rated by previous consumers and the less favorable reviews are in the minority – but, they are still there. There are, of course, better quality mattresses out there but they come with a more substantial cost and you have to question whether or not that’s justified.

Overall, baby crib mattresses, by law in the USA, all have to be deemed safe before they can be mass-produced and sold to consumers. A $60 crib mattress will be as safe as a $600 mattress, so if that’s your main concern, then the Colgate crib mattress is a great option.

However, if you’re looking for a mattress with more robust features, you might want to consider the Newton baby crib mattress instead.

Further read:

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *