Comparisons

One IS Better: Butt Paste vs Desitin Compared

No matter how much you try, your baby is bound to get diaper rash at some point. And in some cases, that rash might turn out to be a lot more severe than you’d expect.

This is where certain creams come in handy and in this case, Butt Paste vs. Desitin, which are both reputable and effective creams for diaper rash in babies.

To prevent diaper rash altogether, always make sure your baby doesn’t sit in wet diapers for too long and when you do change their diaper, make sure your baby’s bottom is completely dry before putting a new diaper on him or her. In the event that your baby already has diaper rash, be sure to pat dry your baby’s bottom before putting on a new diaper or applying any diaper rash cream, whether it be the Butt Paste or Desitin.

Diaper rash can, in a way, be your baby’s first big discomfort or “booboo,” so to speak. In that respect, it might be difficult to watch your baby in so much stinging pain. However, that’s why the active ingredients in these diaper rash creams is there to soothe and help heal your baby’s skin.

While your baby’s rash is healing,  be sure to use unscented baby wipes or even no wipes at all.  Instead, use soft moist towels in order to clean your baby after wet diapers. But even still, be sure to pat dry your baby’s bottom before putting cream and a new diaper on.

Both Butt Paste and Desitin are made with zinc oxide as an active ingredient, which is there to treat the rash in the best way possible, and both creams are meant to be applied liberally over the affected area. Of course, you may find that one of the other works best for your particular baby. This is why it’s important to look at Butt Paste vs. Desitin to really get a feel for which diaper rash cream will work best for your baby in the long run. Because yes, there will be more than one diaper rash in the course of your baby’s diaper-wearing stage.

Boudreaux’s Butt Paste

The main active ingredient in Boudreaux’s Butt Paste is zinc oxide. It is proven to not only treat but also prevent diaper rash. You can almost use it as a preventative measure even before there’s diaper rash. Or, start using it right away after the first signs of a diaper rash to come. Sometimes the rash can spread quickly and get severe and uncomfortable very fast.

The brand has been around for 40 years. So naturally, they’ve developed more than one formula for multiple variations on the diaper rash cream.

If you would rather purchase a cream with natural ingredients, there’s a Butt Paste in a natural variety. And for worse rashes, there’s a maximum strength option as well, and then of course the original. You can even try all three options, depending on your baby’s rash or preference. When using the Butt Paste, you can not only treat baby rash, but also help to seal out moisture after using it, which aids in the healing process.

Features

  • Ingredients: Boudreaux’s Butt Paste is made with 16% zinc oxide, which is more than that of Desitin. The other ingredients are castor seed oil, mineral oil, paraffin, petrolatum, and Myroxylon Balsamum (balsam tolu), and resin.
  • Directions: You can apply the cream liberally after cleaning and drying the affected area. You can use the Butt Paste after each diaper change and even more so at bedtime or naptime.
  • Available Sizes: The cream comes in two, four, and 16-ounce containers.
  • Where To Buy: You can find the cream on Amazon or in-store at Target and Walmart.

Pros

  • Even if your baby doesn’t have a diaper rash, you can use the cream as a preventative measure.
  • Unlike some other diaper rash creams, like Desitin, this particular one doesn’t have a strong smell at all.
  • Even adults can use Butt Paste to treat rashes in unsightly places.
  • It also clears up diaper rashes quickly, regardless of how severe they may be.

Cons

  • At times, it can be hard to completely wipe away the remaining cream after using it or when you need to apply a fresh coat.
  • Since it’s so thick, it can be difficult to spread the cream on babies’ bottoms.
  • The ingredient balsamum can cause rashes in some people, so using the cream for a diaper rash could actually make it worse.
  • In some cases, Butt Paste may cause staining in clothes, so whether its yours or your baby’s, that’s something to keep in mind when using it.

Reviews

“This is the only thing that alleviates my baby’s diaper rashes, and if I use it weekly-ish as a preventative measure he doesn’t seem to get them at all. Combined with a butt brush it’s a great giggle gift to new parents!” – Erica on Amazon.

“We have used several bottom ointments but this is my favorite. My 6-month-old just overcame her first very bad diaper rash. I started with another name brand ointment and then used this. Within 24 hours it decreased dramatically. This is a thick paste but dries in nice and neat. I am not longer using anything but this brand. It does not have a distinct odor. It can be messy but most of them are!” – Emily B. on Amazon.

“Obsessed! I bought this to keep it in my daughter’s diaper bag 4 months ago and I haven’t even used 1/8th of it! It’s the best product IMO for preventing diaper rashes and smells good to boot! My daughter was having a very slight diaper rash last week and it cleared it up in no time!” – Tiffany Ralescu on Amazon.

“This stuff is awesome. My son doesn’t get rashes too often thankfully. But each time he has, this stuff works so quickly! One or two applications and his rash is gone.” – Margaret Mitchell on Amazon.

Desitin Rapid Relief Cream

Most parents know the Desitin brand well. That includes the Desitin Rapid Relief Cream, meant to prevent and treat diaper rash. The hypoallergenic cream can be rubbing on generously in order to help sooth your baby’s rash and seal out wetness before putting a fresh diaper on your little one.

It can also wipe off easily so you won’t be left with goopy messes after each diaper change after. The zinc oxide in the Desitin provides fast relief from diaper rash, with the rash itself noticeably smaller within 12 hours of using it. Plus, it provides extra moisturization on your baby’s skin, even while keeping excess moisture out to heal the affected area.

Although the standard cream is the Rapid Relief option, as well as maximum strength and a multi-purpose skin protectant and rash ointment.

Features

  • Ingredients: The active ingredient in Desitin is 13% zinc oxide.
  • Directions: To treat diaper rash, simply clean and pat dry the rash and then apply a thick amount of the cream to the area before putting a fresh diaper on your baby.
  • Available Sizes: It comes in both tube and tub form and comes in two, four, six, and 16-ounce containers.
  • Where To Buy: You can find the cream on Amazon or in-store at Walgreens and Target.

Pros

  • Desitin acts very quickly after applying it to your baby’s diaper rash.
  • It wipes away from your baby’s skin easily, so it’s relatively easy to apply a fresh coat after each diaper change.
  • It’s thick enough to stay on your baby’s skin without running off on their diaper, so it can really take affect.
  • You can even use Desitin to treat skin conditions or severely dry skin, even if it has nothing to do with your baby.

Cons

  • The smell is relatively strong going on.
  • Unlike the Butt Paste, this is more of a cream, so while it does spread on, it’s not as thick.
  • Since creams like this work differently on different babies, there’s a chance that the Desitin could actually make your baby’s rash worse.

Reviews

“Works like a charm to get rid of diaper rash. It does take multiple application for couple of days to totally get rid of diaper rash but if you are diligent about changing baby’s diaper frequently and applying this cream, it does the trick.” – Andy S. on Amazon.

“Best baby rash ointment! When I first brought home my baby boy, he had gotten a diaper rash. While his skin was adjusting to his new environment, we went through a bunch of this ointment. It cleared his skin right up! I then used it to protect his little behind. Now I use it as needed. Great product. Worth every penny.” – Ariana Cagle on Amazon.

“I’ve used several different types of “butt paste” for my daughter’s diaper rashes and this one is by far the best. By the next diaper change the rash is almost completely gone. I always carry this around in my diaper bag for whenever she gets one. She can be crying in pain from it while I change her diaper and it soothes her within minutes once applied.” – Kristen Breen on Amazon.

“Desitin is a staple at my house with my two great-grandchildren! Works great and the price is fantastic! Better than most more expensive brands!” – Randi Odierno on Amazon.

The Verdict

It is easy to see the benefits of both the Bitt Paste and Desitin diaper rash creams. In addition, the stronger option is going to have to be Boudreaux’s Butt Paste.

It’s much thicker than most other diaper rash creams and is virtually odorless, so you won’t have to worry about any fishy smells when applying it to your baby’s bottom.

It also helps prevent rashes and then clear them up in record time. Or, at the very least, it will help start to clear up diaper rashes soon after applying it to the affected area. While it’s true that Desitin also offers this feature, you just can’t look past the thick consistency that the Bitt Paste offers while working to heal your baby’s severe rashes.

Butt Paste is also affordable for most families and since it’s so thick, you’ll only need to use small amounts each time you apply it to your baby’s diaper rash. As the individual reviews also state, you can begin using Butt Paste at the first signs of a diaper rash and see a noticeable difference just 24 hours later, which is a huge plus to keep your baby from being too uncomfortable for too long.

Final Thoughts

Most diaper rash creams can also be used to treat rashes and dry skin ailments in adults as well, so whether you go with the Desitin or Butt Paste, you’ll be getting a diaper rash cream that has more than one use for both you and your little one.

And since every cream will react differently with different babies, you may find that one of these works better than the others, despite any reviews or better features that one may have. Between the two, the stronger option is the Butt Paste, but at the end of the day, it’s going to be your choice in deciding which is the better value and which has all of the qualities your baby really needs.

Leave a Reply