Most people think about the brand and the price of a product before buying it. This is also the case when it comes to baby formulas, especially organic ones which are obviously more expensive. Still, the products I’m about to review today are both popular brands. Moreover, they are both suitable breast milk replacements.
So, what are their main differences and which one should you purchase? You’re about to find all that information in the sections written below.
Bottom Line Up Front Summary: I definitely recommend going with HiPP organic formula as the ingredients are higher quality, bio-dynamic certified, and with fewer additives. Remember to use code THEBABYSWAG at checkout here for 5% off.
Jump to a specific section
- Baby’s Only vs Hipp – High-Level Comparison
- Baby’s Only Organic Formula
- Hipp Certified Organic Baby Formula
- Baby’s Only vs Hipp – Ingredient Profile
- Baby’s Only vs Hipp – Pros and Cons
- Baby’s Only vs Hipp – Taste, and Tolerance
- Baby’s Only vs Hipp – How Much Do These Organic Formulas Cost?
- Baby’s Only vs Hipp – the Final Verdict
Baby’s Only vs Hipp – High-Level Comparison
Baby’s Only Organic Formula
According to the manufacturer, Baby’s Only is an organic formula that contains some of the purest ingredients you could imagine. The company applies strict regulatory standards and they don’t compromise on the product’s quality when it comes to investing time and money into creating one of the best baby formulas on the market.
There are several different organic formulas marketed under this brand: Baby’s Only Organic Dairy Formula with DHA and ARA oils, Baby’s Only Toddler Formula (organic kosher) Dairy-Based and Iron-Fortified, lactose-free alternative, and soy-based formula.
Hipp Certified Organic Baby Formula
Hipp is an organic replacement for breast milk that’s produced in Europe. This is a product that’s gentle on your baby’s stomach and it is completely free from chemicals and pesticides. The main ingredient is sourced from free-range cows and the company performs several quality tests at every single phase of production.
Like Baby’s Only, Hipp also markets a wide range of milk powder types and formulas: milk starter pack, milk powder for infants, Follow on Milk powder, Hungry Infant milk replacement powder, Growing Up milk powder, Comfort milk formula, anti-reflux milk powder, etc.
Baby’s Only vs Hipp – Ingredient Profile
Baby’s Only Ingredients
Here’s a list of the ingredients included in this formula:
- Brown rice syrup;
- High oleic sunflower and safflower oil;
- Nonfat milk;
- Coconut oil;
- Soybean oil;
- Calcium Phosphate;
- Egg lecithin;
- Potassium Citrate;
- Organic vanilla;
- Zinc sulfate;
- Vitamin B2;
- Sodium Selenate;
- Vitamin B12;
- Vitamin D3; etc.
The manufacturer, Nature’s Only was created back in 1997 and has soon become a leader in organic baby formulas. According to the company’s representatives, their products should only be used as a secondary food because breast milk should be every mom’s first option. Nevertheless, their formula is safe and nutritious for both newborns and toddlers.
The formula comes with two types of fatty acids derived from egg yolks that can also be found in breast milk: DHA and ARA. In fact, that’s the main reason why many manufacturers include them in their baby products in the attempt to mimic breast milk. These two compounds play a major role in the child’s development process.
Regarding the aforementioned fatty acids, one thing has troubled parents: the method through which DHA and ARA are extracted (many companies use hexane which is a chemical). Fortunately, Baby’s Only is definitely an exception because their extraction process is hexane-free. On the other hand, if your baby is allergic to either eggs or fish, you won’t be able to use this formula.
Another issue that you must consider is the amount of artificial sweetener included in the formula which can lead to several problems such as constipation and an upset stomach. This happens because these ingredients aren’t naturally found in breast milk.
Baby’s Only Formula Nutritional Information – per 100 ml
One of the things that set HiPP apart from Baby’s Only is given by its lactose content and lack of artificial sweeteners. Here’s a list of Hipp’s ingredients:
- Whey protein powder;
- Skimmed milk;
- Vegetable oils;
- Potassium Citrate;
- Fish oil;
- Calcium Carbonate;
- Vitamin mix – A, B1, C, B6, B12, E, K, D, etc.;
- Mineral mix – zinc, iron, sodium, etc.
There are certain differences between Hipp formula options, depending on the purpose they serve. Still, all products are free from wheat, gluten, peanut, nut, and other potentially allergenic compounds. However, if your baby doesn’t tolerate lactose, Hipp might not be the right formula for your infant.
Hipp Organic Formula Nutritional Information – per one serving (2 level scoops)
Baby’s Only vs Hipp – Pros and Cons
Baby’s Only Advantages
- This product is formulated with pure and high-quality organic ingredients that are certified and approved by the USDA;
- It’s free from gluten or corn-based compounds which makes it a great choice for infants who are allergic to these elements;
- Contains high-quality oils (DHA and ARA) sourced from egg yolks;
- The ingredients aren’t extracted with hexane.
Baby’s Only Disadvantages
- Has rice syrup as a sweetener;
- Some say that the formula’s casein content is way too high;
- It has a high amount of brown rice syrup which has been found to contain traces of arsenic in several cases.
- It’s a safe and natural formula with non-GMO ingredients;
- It doesn’t contain any artificial sweeteners or other fishy ingredients;
- Comes with a lowered heavy metal content;
- Provides a higher amount of healthy fatty acids which support proper brain development;
- Hipp markets several different formula types created for each stage of your baby’s growth.
- It contains lactose which, although it is a high-quality protein, isn’t the best choice for lactose-intolerant babies;
- A few moms have complained that Hipp’s packaging system is quite annoying and that there are other options out there that are easier to use and prepare;
- Some say that the powdered version tastes different from the company’s ready-to-drink options.
Baby’s Only vs Hipp – Taste, and Tolerance
Baby’s Only Formula
Luckily, this product doesn’t have a goofy smell or an unpleasant taste both of which are considered major pluses. In fact, the majority of moms who have purchased Baby’s Only organic formula were happy with the way the powder smells and, according to them, their infants have also enjoyed the product’s taste. Unlike other baby formulas, this one doesn’t come with that fishy or metal smell that new moms are so familiar with.
Regarding the tolerance level, most moms state that their little ones tolerate this formula pretty well. Furthermore, the product has helped many babies with their skin issues, colic symptoms, and other minor health problems that are usually linked to the consumption of standard formulas.
Still, there are a few parents who have claimed that Baby’s Only caused constipation in their infants. The general opinion is that this specific issue might be created by the formula’s high casein amount.
Another potential problem is represented by the product’s brown rice syrup content which can be quite hard to digest, especially for babies who have a more sensitive stomach. This doesn’t mean that it will be the case with your kid; the main idea is that every baby is unique and his or her organism reacts differently.
Hipp Organic Formula
When it comes to how this formula tastes, there are plenty of different opinions. Some parents are pleased with it while others say it has a pretty weird taste although it isn’t sweet. A few moms have even admitted they add a small vanilla drop to the mix in order to achieve a better taste than their infants won’t refuse or dislike.
With Hipp, you shouldn’t worry about tolerance because all the company’s products are hypoallergenic and they are smooth on your baby’s digestive system. In fact, Hipp has come up with different milk replacement varieties that tackle specific infant issues such as colic, allergies, intolerances, gas reflux, and constipation. For instance, if your little one deals with regurgitation or reflux, you should opt for Hipp’s Combiotic anti-reflux formula.
Baby’s Only vs Hipp – How Much Do These Organic Formulas Cost?
Baby’s Only Formula
Although the label states that Baby’s Only Organic Formula is appropriate for toddlers, you can safely feed it to your newborn as well. As a matter of fact, the company chose to write “toddler formula” on the package as an attempt to encourage mothers to feed their infants with breast milk at first. One can of Baby’s Only milk powder measures 12.7 ounces which will probably last you for a couple of days.
The price of this product is very reasonable, especially if you think about its high-quality organic ingredients and the company’s strict regulations. On the other hand, some people seem to perceive the cost of the formula a tad high considering it comes with certain questionable compounds and it lacks other essential elements like lactose and whey protein.
On Amazon, you will find the following varieties of milk powder produced under Baby’s Only brand:
- Baby’s Only Organic DHA & ARA dairy baby formula – a pack of 5
- Dairy-based organic kosher toddler formula – a pack of 3 containers
- The lactose-free variety that’s also fortified with iron – a pack of 6 cans
- Baby’s Only Soy-Based Iron-Fortified formula – is currently unavailable on Amazon but you can purchase it from Nature’s One.
Hipp Organic Baby Formula
Hipp is available in the following sizes and packs:
- The infant milk starter pack
- pack of 4 milk powder containers of the Combiotic first infant milk formula
- The Hungry Infant Milk Powder variety (a pack of 4 cans);
- Hipp Organic Combiotic “follow on milk”;
- A 4-pack of Hipp Growing Up Milk powder (each container measures around 21 ounces);
- The anti-reflux variety;
- The Comfort Milk alternative created to alleviate symptoms of constipation and colic is (a pack of 4 cans).
Where to Buy HiPP Organic Formula Online
You can purchase any variety of Hipp organic formulas from the following vendors:
- MyOrganicCompany.store: They typically have the lowest prices that I’ve found here, but we also have a reader’s discount code: use THEBABYSWAG at checkout to save 10%!
- LittleBundle.com: They have the deepest selection of HiPP products that we’ve found, with the fastest shipping and a strong supply chain (rarely out of stock). Use code TBS5OFF at checkout for 5% off.
- OrganicBabyFood.shop: New player but good selection of HiPP products + bulk discounts available. Use code BABYSWAG5 at checkout for 5% off your entire order (including bulk).
Baby’s Only vs Hipp – the Final Verdict
Baby’s Only is more popular than Hipp in terms of brand awareness. Many parents are pleased with the fact that this formula contains a lot of good-quality ingredients and it tries to mimic breast milk. So, with time, clients’ expectations have grown and the manufacturer tries its best to keep up with those expectations. The only downsides I could find about Baby’s Only organic formula are related to its casein and brown rice syrup content.
Hipp, on the other hand, is also a very good choice if you’re looking for a natural and organic formula. It has non-GMO ingredients and it is very gentle on your infant’s stomach. Also, Hipp is suitable since birth and it provides a wide range of nutrients and essential elements like prebiotics and Omega-3 fatty acids.
Bottom Line: I definitely recommend going with HiPP organic formula for the above reasons. Remember to use code THEBABYSWAG at checkout here for 5% off.
In the end, the choice is all yours. These two formulas have plenty of similarities but also certain differences. Just make sure to check the label, think about your baby’s needs, and, if necessary, seek the opinion of your pediatrician.
- Baby’s Only vs. Earth’s Best Formula: Which is The Best For Your Needs?
- Holle vs. Baby’s Only Formula: Which one is Best?
- Baby’s Only vs HiPP
- HiPP vs Loulouka Non GMO Formula
- HiPP vs Lebenswert European Formula
- One IS Better: Hipp vs Holle Organic Formulas Compared
- HiPP vs Aptamil Compared
- Where to Buy Baby Formula Online
- Top Formula for Gassy Infants